The first season of the television series How I Met Your Mother aired on January 9, 2006, on CBS. Ted Mosby initially meets Robin Scherbatsky and invites her to be his plus one at a wedding. However, his plans lead to unexpected trouble with the bride and groom, and Ted worries about finding a date for his friends Claudia.
The 12th episode of the first season, “The Wedding,” follows Ted and Robin’s relationship, which is revealed over three seasons. The story revolves around Barney and Robin’s wedding, where the identity of the bride and groom is revealed. The wedding date changes from season eight to season nine, and the show has been controversial due to the decision to reveal the mother’s identity and then speed through her life, kill her off, and pair Ted back with Robin in the end.
The ending of the show is controversial, with fan disappointment over the decision to reveal the mother’s identity and then speed through her life, kill her off, and pair Ted back with Robin in the end. The show also features a series of events, such as Robin’s marriage to Barney Stinson and her engagement to Stuart and Claudia.
In the future, Ted pretends he isn’t married 20 years in the future before revealing a wedding ring on his hand. In May 2021, Robin marries Barney, but she has some momentary misgivings when she debates running away with Ted instead. The show concludes with the wedding, marking the end of the first season of How I Met Your Mother.
📹 Robin tells Ted not to marry Stella (How I Met Your Mother 4×5)
Robin travels all the way from Japan to attend Ted’s wedding, even though she thinks it’s too weird, cos there’s still something …
In which episode do Ted and Robin get together?
The How I Met Your Mother finale revealed that Barney and Robin divorced, while Ted and Tracy are about to get married. In the last episode, Ted told his kids the sad news that Tracy had died. Ted decides to pursue Robin again, and they end up together when he arrives at her home with a blue French horn.
Why did Robin and Barney divorce?
Romantic relationships. Robin Scherbatsky. Barney and Robin start out as friends, but he falls in love with her after they sleep together. In Season 4, he struggles with his feelings for her until they finally get together in the season finale, The Leap. They become a couple in season 5, but break up in The Rough Patch because they’re making each other miserable. They never fully get over each other, even when they date other people. In the eighth season, he plans to win Robin’s heart (with Ted’s future wife’s help). He proposes to her. She says yes, and they get engaged. The final season is about their wedding. After thinking it over, they get married. In the series finale, Last Forever, they get divorced after three years because Robin’s work schedule prevents them from spending time together. They don’t see each other for years, until Ted’s wedding. The series ends with Barney and Robin getting back together after Ted’s wedding. This shows that Barney always loved Robin and always will. She got him to settle down in the first place, and it is never too late for them. Barney has two other girlfriends. Nora (Nazanin Boniadi) is the other woman. He cheats with her and ends the relationship in hopes that Robin will do the same with Kevin. However, he is heartbroken when he finds out that Robin chose Kevin. Barney also had a serious relationship with Quinn, a stripper. He proposed, but they broke up because they didn’t trust each other.
Appearances outside How I Met Your Mother. In 2008, Barney wrote The Bro Code. Three other books written by Barney: Bro on the Go, The Playbook, and Bro Code for Parents: What to Expect When You’re Awesome was also published.
Which episode does Ted get married?
The Wedding (How I Met Your Mother) How I Met Your Mother episode Episode no. Season 1, Episode 12 Directed by Pamela Fryman Written by Kourtney Kang and Ashley Williams Starring Matt Boren The Wedding is the 12th episode in the first season of the television series How I Met Your Mother. It aired on CBS on January 9, 2006.
Plotted. In 2006, Ted worries about finding a date for his friends Claudia and Stuart’s wedding. When Robin breaks up with Derek, Ted invites her to the wedding and she accepts. But when Ted meets Claudia two days before the wedding, she says he said he was coming alone on his RSVP card and forbids him from bringing a date. Ted tries to tell Robin he can’t take her to the wedding, but changes his mind when he sees her wedding dress.
Do Ted and Robin get married on How I Met Your Mother?
How he relates to other characters. Robin Scherbatsky. In the pilot, Ted meets Robin at MacLarens, the bar the main characters hang out at. They go on a date, and Ted tells her he loves her. They decide to be friends, but they still love each other. Ted and Robin start dating. They last as a couple for a year until they break up at the end of the second season. They remain friends and are roommates between the fourth and seventh seasons. Ted and Robin become good friends and support each other. The two go on to see other people and seem fine until Robin and Barney sleep together in the third season, which causes a rift. Ted gets over it and supports Robin and Barney. Ted never gets over Robin. He is confused when she and Barney get engaged. He wants her to be happy, but he still thinks he and Robin are meant to be together. Ted decides not to win Robin back because he sees that Barney makes her happy. He decides to move to Chicago after their wedding. On the day of Robin’s wedding, she tries to run off with Ted, but he knows it won’t work. That night, Ted meets Tracy McConnell and they fall in love. The series ends in 2030, with Tracy dead six years before. Ted’s kids encourage him to date Robin. He brings her the blue French horn he stole on their first date. She smiles at him with tears in her eyes. A deleted scene shows Lily and Marshall together.
Does Ted marry Robin after Tracy dies?
Barney and Robin’s marriage doesn’t last, and neither does Ted’s because Tracy dies after having two children with the couple (as many fans and critics of the show had predicted). At the end of the episode, Ted and Robin get back together. The creators of the show, Carter Bays and Craig Thomas, knew the plot for the final episode when the series started nine years ago. They kept the story going because they knew they had to. Some of Monday’s finale was filmed in 2006 because the teen actors who played Ted’s kids would have become unrecognizable. Most of the last season is set in one weekend. Robin and Barney’s wedding. Tracy was the bass player in the wedding band. The final episode jumps ahead several years. We learn that Robin and Barney get divorced three years after their wedding because of Robin’s success as a TV correspondent. After their divorce, Robin is pushed out of the gang.
Who finally becomes Ted’s wife?
The Mother (How I Met Your Mother) Tracy McConnell Alias The Mother, T.M. Gender Female Spouse Ted Mosby (m. 2020) Significant others Max (boyfriend, deceased) Louis (ex-boyfriend) Tracy Mosby (née McConnell) (The Mother) is the title character from the CBS television sitcom How I Met Your Mother. The show is about how Ted Mosby met his kids’ mom. Tracy McConnell appears in eight episodes, from “Lucky Penny” to “The Time Travelers.” She was first seen in the season 8 finale, “Something New,” and was promoted to a main character in season 9. She is played by Cristin Milioti. The story of how Ted met The Mother is the series’ main plot. It reveals that Ted once owned her umbrella and accidentally left it in her apartment. Ted and The Mother meet at the Farhampton train station after Barney and Robin’s wedding. This scene is in Last Forever, the series finale. Fans reacted differently to the 2024 reveal that The Mother died from an unspecified illness.
Casting edit. How I Met Your Mother often hinted at the unseen character of The Mother during its first eight seasons. Many well-known actresses appeared on the show as guests. Many fans thought another actress would play the role, but the creators wanted an unknown. Thomas said we didn’t want a big, famous star because we didn’t want the audience to have associations with the actress. The idea is that Ted has never seen this woman before, so it should feel that way to the audience. Cobie Smulders being cast as Robin Scherbatsky kept the show alive when it began. They didn’t want a big casting call.
Why did Barney and Robin get a divorce?
The last season is about Barney and Robin’s wedding. After some hesitation, they get married in The End of the Aisle. He vows to always be honest with her. Three years after their wedding, they get divorced because Robin’s busy schedule keeps them apart. Barney has meaningless sex with multiple women for several years. He thinks that if he can’t form a lasting relationship with Robin, he can’t form one with anyone else. Then one of his one-night stands gets pregnant. He hates being a father until his daughter, Ellie, is born. He falls in love with her and becomes a devoted father. The series ends with Barney and Robin getting back together. In the second season premiere of How I Met Your Father, Sophie hits Barney’s car. He tells every woman he meets that he is in recovery and apologizes if he tricked them into having sex with him. He also wears an ankle bracelet that shocks him every time he says something sexually inappropriate. He and Sophie bond over growing up without a father. He inspires her to look for hers.
Childhood and family Some people have said what Barney’s birthday is. In Natural History, Barney says he was six on July 23, 1981. This puts his birthday between July 24, 1974 and July 23, 1975. In Zoo or False, Ted says Barney was born seven years after the Moon landing (in July 1969). In Columns set in 2007, Barney gives his age as 31, confirming he was born in 1976. Marshall says Barney is a Scorpio, so his birthday is between October 23 and November 21, 1976.
Why did Ted not marry Robin?
Season 7. Ted and Robin share a cigar on the balcony of Punchy’s wedding. Ted talks to Robin about how everyone else is in a relationship, while he is still single. Robin tells Ted to believe in love again and wait for the right person. She also tells him not to cry during the toast. The Naked Truth – Robin tries to get Ted to take her to the Architects ball. Ducky Tie – Victoria tells Ted that Robin is more important to him than he realizes. She says they can’t hang out at the bar all the time like they’re just friends. That doesn’t work. Trust me. Future Ted agrees with her. It didn’t work. We didn’t realize it yet. Symphony of Illumination: Ted cheers Robin up with an elaborate Christmas display. The Burning Beekeeper: Robin and Ted fight over Robin’s temper and Ted’s fear of confrontation. They make up and tell each other their quirks make them cool. Robin reveals she’s infertile and that’s why her engagement with Kevin ended. Ted says he can forgive her because he loves her. Robin thinks about his proposal. No Pressure – Ted thinks this is his chance to win back Robin, but Lily says he hasn’t settled down with her either. Robin says she doesn’t love Ted because she just broke up with her boyfriend. Ted says they can’t be single at 40. Marshall tells Robin to leave. Lily bet Marshall that Ted and Robin wouldn’t end up together. At the end of the episode, Lily tells Marshall to pay up, but he says not yet. This shows that Ted and Robin are not done yet. Karma – Ted ignores Robin for weeks after she rejected him. He decides what to do with her old room. They don’t hang out much. The Broath – Ted and Robin compete over Quinn’s apartment. Robin gets a promotion and more money at work and finds another apartment. She tells Quinn to give the apartment to Ted. Now We’re Even – Ted and Robin are still awkward around each other, but a near-fatal helicopter crash makes Ted finally text Robin to let her know that he’s glad she’s okay. Good Crazy – Barney tries to hook Ted up with various women, but Ted keeps imagining Robin. He goes to find her, but she’s in labor. With Marvins birth, Ted and Robin reconcile. Robin urges him to go after Victoria because she’s the one that got away. Ted and Robin compete over who has the best relationship, but both admit they’re not happy with their partners. Victoria agrees to Ted’s proposal, but only if he stops seeing Robin. She thinks Robin is holding up their relationship. Ted says Robin is like family and he can’t stop seeing her. She breaks up with him and says she hopes he gets Robin one day. Ted doesn’t tell Robin, but Future Ted says Robin will find out. Ted helps Robin sneak into Barney’s apartment. The Final Page – Part Two – Ted asks Robin to be his date to the GNB Tower party. He knows Barney is proposing to Patrice, so he urges Robin to stop Barney. Ted is sad that Robin married Barney. Ted cancels a meeting with a client to help Robin find her locket, which was meant to be her something old. He says the locket isn’t a sign she shouldn’t marry Barney. She reaches for his hand and looks at him. Something New – Robin got drunk and upset that she wasn’t going to marry Ted when he got engaged to Stella. She dug up her locket, which she was going to wear when she married Ted. Ted finds the locket in his apartment. Ted gives Robin a photo of the group from 8 years ago as a wedding gift. It’s revealed that Robin’s locket might be in LA. Last Time in New York: Ted and Lily discuss Ted moving to Chicago because of Robin. The Broken Code: Barney finds out that Ted has feelings for Robin. Ted tries to get over her. Platonic: In a flashback, it is revealed that Ted thought he had all the time in the world to pursue Robin again while Barney was actually planning to propose to her. Marshall says Ted can still get Robin, but Lily thinks they’re just friends. Ted and Robin take advantage of a drunk Barney. They talk about when they used to date. Sunrise – Ted and Robin talk about his past relationships and he finally lets go of her. Victoria gave Ted the locket, but Jeanette got it and threw it in the pond. Robin thinks she should be with Ted because he’s dependable. Robin panics about her wedding in False Positive. She realizes Ted found her locket and thinks it might be a sign she shouldn’t marry Barney. Ted says Robin loves Barney and that he’d never hurt him. In her panic, she thinks about running away. First, she uses Ted as an excuse, but when he doesn’t agree, she decides to run away by herself. Her fears are assuaged by Barney’s promise to be honest with her. Last Forever – Part One: In a flashback to 2005, Barney is jealous when Robin becomes Ted’s wingman. In 2015, Robin is disappointed when Ted talks about his wedding to Tracy. Tracy tells Ted the wedding needs to be called off because she’s pregnant. Robin is jealous. In 2016, Robin explains to Lily that Ted was the guy she should have ended up with. Last Forever – Part Two – In the series finale in 2020, Ted and Robin bump into each other and are happy to see each other. In a deleted scene, they meet for lunch the next day. She tells Ted she was meant to be with him. She goes to Ted’s wedding after Tracy convinces her. In 2030, Ted’s kids let him start seeing Robin again. They say they love her and that they’ve been through a lot together. It turns out that Robin’s mom died six years ago, and she’s become a big part of Ted and his kids’ lives. Ted appears at Robin’s window with the blue French horn, as in the pilot and the end of Season 1. Robin cries and smiles as the series ends. A deleted scene showed they got back together.
Did Robin get pregnant with Barney?
Plottedit. This episode starts with Robin telling her kids about the time she told their dad she was pregnant. The scene cuts to Barney and Robin in the bathroom of Marshall and Lily’s Long Island house. Robin explains she is a week late with her period and has a doctor’s appointment to find out if she is pregnant. She also says they haven’t had sex yet, so if she’s pregnant, Barney is the father. Barney is happy about becoming a father, but Robin doesn’t want kids. Barney shares her concerns when he sees how Insane Duane’s life has changed since he married and had children. Robin and Barney are relieved when the doctor says she isn’t pregnant. Robin celebrates not being pregnant for a day until she learns she can’t have kids. Robin lies to her friends and says she’s disappointed she didn’t make the Canadian women’s pole vaulting team. The others notice Robin is acting strange and try to figure out why. Ted thinks Robin is homesick for Canada after she and Barney joke about hooking up. Ted offers Robin plane tickets to visit him in Cleveland, Ohio, for Christmas. Robin says no and says he shouldn’t feel responsible for cheering her up. She goes for a walk in Central Park. She realizes the kids she’s telling the story to don’t exist. She’s talking to herself on a park bench. She’s coming to terms with her bad news. She goes back to the apartment and finds a Christmas light display with AC/DC music. Ted put it up. He says she doesn’t have to tell him what happened, but he’ll cheer her up. Robin cries and Ted comforts her. Future Ted tells his kids that Robin never became a pole vaulter, but did become a famous journalist, traveled the world and even enjoyed a stint as a bullfighter. He also notes that she was never alone. Meanwhile, Marshall wants to have better Christmas decorations than Richard Holdman. He plans an entire display, which he names the Symphony of Illumination for the Long Island house, complete with Mannheim Steamroller Christmas music. He accepts help from Scott, a neighbor. Scott leaves Marshall on the roof, takes his phone, and texts Lily. He also throws a party in Marshall’s house. Marshall is angry when he sees Scott using a stocking his grandmother made for him. He stays on the roof until Lily comes. She pays Scott $50 for helping him. Then she sees the damage he did inside the house.
Who did Ted end up with?
In the series finale, Ted married Tracy, the mother of his children.
Who does Robin finally end up with?
How I Met Your Mother was a divisive series finale. People had issues with Robin ending up with Ted. Some viewers wanted her to stay with Barney. Fans of both couples have reasons for why they believe their couple should have ended up together. There’s plenty of evidence to argue for both matches. Fans of the shared universe are hoping to see more cameos of the original cast in future seasons of How I Met Your Father. New appearances could help viewers understand why certain decisions were made. You can stream both shows on Hulu.
Who does Ted finally marry?
In the series finale, Ted married Tracy, the mother of his children.
So, you breakup with a guy for nothing who can even die for you, then you come to his wedding and tell him not to marry because you might someday want to settle with him but not at this moment. You aren’t gonna propose him or accept him, but you are telling him to not get married. What level of Friendzone is it?
Later on, this exact same thing will happen with Barney (except that Barney did it on purpose), she always wants what she can’t have. That’s not healthy. When she and Barney get divorced she falls for Ted all over again and probably a big reason of why that happened is because he was married now. I’m not saying she dosen’t love Ted or that she didn’t love Barney but that love is based on a twisted mindset of wanting what you can’t have. And he totally made it rain.
OK, I’m going to back up Robin here. She wants what she can’t have because she’s used to being pushed away/hurt in love., it’s what she learned. Ted was a massive curve ball for her, she couldn’t accept him because he was unfamiliar, he was what she wanted but didn’t feel worthy of. Enter Barney, a reminder of her emotionally distant father and bam, we have wedding (not an accident) but she could never be happy. Ted was always it for her, she just couldn’t accept it until she could feel worthy of him. The fact is, she always was.
She knows marrying Stella is not good for Ted. That’s why she says “you’re disappearing into someone else’s house, someone else’s life”. Because marrying Stella meant Ted has to move to her house, take care of her kid. He always wanted to build and grow a family. But now he’s just going along with whatever Stella already has. That’s less than what he deserves. Robin was really brave to say these to Ted when his other friends couldn’t. Knowing that saying all these would make Ted hate her she still wanted the best for him.
This scene shows how Robin did care for Ted. Someone who wouldn’t care would not even bother saying all that. You can tell it’s from the heart. And she is on her journey, she hasn’t made it yet, so to her, if she ever did want to settle down, it would be with Ted. People don’t consider timing, but it plays a role in a story.
One of the most crucial scenes of the series that goes widely unremembered. It’s great to see Robin as a character that is not necessarily evil, but human. Selfish. Love in their 50’s doesn’t have to be a passionate love affair like Ted/Tracy or Marshall/Lily. It can simply be two friends who have good sexual chemistry and want to share the rest of their lives together. It happens all the time when widows in their 60s remarry. The ending (in theory) ISN’T bad. S9 was just ill-developed with the wedding arc being one of the most idiotic creative choices in sitcom history.
Reminds me of Rachel going to break up Ross’ wedding in London. Let’s face it Robin doesn’t want Ted to marry Stella because she’s not over him, the same reason why Rachel doesn’t want Ross to be with Emily. Oh Ted keep denying there’s nothing between you and Robin anymore. Why else did you invite her–your ex-to your own wedding?!
After all this time, I agree with both of them. Robin is right that that’s not the grand wedding and love that Ted loves deserves in her eyes, because she knows that Ted is a huge romantic guy. It comes mostly from a place of love. But on the other side, she also has a bit of a questionable and selfish intent (and a bit rude) with this, like Ted said she doesn’t want to lose him as a backup boyfriend she can come back to if she doesn’t find someone else.
Robin was just telling Ted what he needed to hear. Stella was just a rebound, and so were the other girls he dated. It came from a good place, it was just the fact that it came from his ex-girlfriend. Ted broke up with Robin because they wanted different things. If they had continued to date, they would have been miserable. In season 2, there were signs they were headed for a breakup because they wanted different things. They didn’t connect on a lot of other levels. Sometimes love isn’t enough. Ted eventually did end up with someone he deserved. But Robin was who he always wanted to be with. Robin also deserved what she wanted out of life, career and traveling. She got that. She found out she couldn’t have kids. They were all young people, and they all had moments of doubt of what they wanted. Lilly called off her wedding to pursue art, Marshall had doubts about when he and Lilly wanted to get pregnant, and Ted went from fling after fling, and Barney had some people he dated, too. They were all growing in different ways and wanting different things. Robin got what she wanted, but there was always something missing. I think this show was pretty brilliant for showing one woman didn’t fantasize about the conventional roles; wanting to get married, and have a bunch of kids and stay at home Mom. She knew what she wanted, but she never got what she needed. She could have had it with Barney, but even Barney went back to his old ways when they divorced. He didn’t want kids either-until he had a daughter.
This is one of the best scenes in TV history for me. I love how during the seriousness of the scene, Ted says, “I did make it rain” and she says, “It was a coincidence.” It wasn’t just comedic genius, it also was why their love didn’t work. It’s why they couldn’t grow old together. That’s way too big a gap to get past. I wish the writers realized this.
Saying Robin didn’t love Ted is a big blunder. Ted feeling miserable about her marrying Barney is very visible, but her marrying Barney was them bringing their relationship to a conclusion, and Robin said it no other terms when she compared him to her Lobster allergy. She felt depressed about Stella, she was heartbroken about Tracy
I always thought this scene showed Robin’s emotional maturity about how even though she knows what she and Ted want are completely different things, it doesn’t make Ted’s desires for a wife and kids something to sneer at – she tries to counsel him as a friend with some real talk by reminding him that he deserves to have his dreams fulfilled the right way with someone who loves him back with just as much quirkiness and zeal
For me Robin and Ted are just perfect. They’ve both always been in love to each other. Robin has always been in love with Ted but she didn’t chose him bc she knew she couldn’t give him the family with kids he wanted so bad, she chose his happiness over hers and that’s true love!! The ending couldn’t have been any more perfect!!
If we really think about it, everything ended well. Like as we later on realise that Robin couldn’t conceive a child at all, the life Ted always wanted, nay deserved. She couldn’t just give Ted that life. In the end Ted has kids…became a loving dad and supportive kids who accept Robin and eventually Ted gets to be with the woman he always wanted.
The problem I have with this scene is that Robin’s criticism is basically that Ted should not marry someone with a kid, which in my opinion is complete crap. Yes, Ted and Stella tried to get married to soon, but that is not her argument. Love often requires sacrifice and Ted as a character is always the first person who will sacrifice in a relationship. Moving into your wife’s house in a different state may not be ideal but it is something that you do if you care about someone.
Even though Robin shouldn’t gave been the person telling ted all this considering she is his ex and didn’t want to marry him and now she is stopping him from marrying someone else. But she does have a point though. She was right ted was rushing into this. Honestly ted and Stella didn’t even seem that much in loveor maybe it’s just me. But robin did the right thing by stopping him.
I don’t really like Robin, in hindsight, because she is an envious, self centered, abrasive jerk with a borderline hair-trigger temper. I especially dislike the character, since her fatal flaws are all traits I struggle with to a certain degree (abrasiveness less so), and yet she makes little effort to overcome them. I believe that she should have ended up with neither Barney nor Ted (Nora should have ended up with Barney, Tracy shouldn’t have been killed off). She may be a good worker, but she doesn’t function well in romantic relationships. It’s no wonder, in my opinion, that Ted tries to portray her as a Romantic False Lead, in contrast to Tracy’s Manic Pixie Dream Girl. Ted has reasons not to want to end up with her, and tries to tell the story accordingly, remaining in denial. Unfortunately, his kids realize that he is attracted to Robin, and manipulate him into continuing the story so they can try to convince him to move on from Tracy’s untimely demise. Again, why HER? That said, Robin’s not wrong about Ted’s intention to marry Stella Zinman being a HUGE mistake. In hindsight, Stella’s amicable personality comes off as a facade, while at least Robin is honest about her personality in comparison.
I DON T UNDESTAND ROBIN…SHE LEFT HER WORK IN TOKYO FOR TED AND SHE DOESN’T WANT ANGAGED WITH HIM?….SHE SAID SO CAUSE SHE S AFRAID TO LOSE HIM FOREVER CAUSE HE S GETTING MARRIED BUT THEN, WHEN TED TOLD HER THAT HE LOVES HER, SHE REPLY NO?…ROBIN WILL UNDERSTAND SHE LOVES TED AT THE END OF THE SERIE..
00:51 See? That’s why I don’t like Robin at all. She didn’t overthink to stop and say “I still feel something for Ted” when she was about to have sex with Barney. That makes no sense. This show would be so much better if Ted was the one who actually died instead of Tracy, and actually, she was reading his words out of some kind of diary he decided to write down.
And even Ted’s storyline had this huge story line about this Mother and you think she is going to be perfect. But when she comes into the season, she is barely in it and she is boring. We didn’t even get to know her. The ending was all predictable. Why would you sit your kids down and say you were telling them about your Mother, when it was clear he was in love with this other woman. The. whole. time.
Even if he really was rushing things, he at least deserves the illusion of having a happy marriage and family. Something Robin wasn’t willing to give him. He deserved more, we all agree, but how much does he has to wait ’till he gets it? He’s supposed to wait 10 more years until the girl of his dreams finally appear?
I never liked her character. She always switched. She played with people’s feeling. One day she wanted Ted, then Barney, then kissed Ted right after Kevin broke up with her. Granted she said she didn’t love Ted afterwards but still, how do you always play with people’s emotions. She wanted a guy who comes thru for her but both of them did in their own ways. But not her.Ted was always her fallback guy and she knew it. I didn’t like the ending for this reason. Robin did not deserve to end up with Ted. Ted deserved someone else. Would have been better if he ended up with Victoria somehow.