The Swedish wedding tradition involves the bride carrying coins in her shoes, symbolizing the love and support of her parents. The tradition is based on an old superstition that the bride would receive a gold coin from her mother and a silver coin from her father on the morning of the wedding. This practice ensures that the bride will never go without money, bringing luck, financial stability, and a sense of family heritage to her married life.
The tradition also includes a bridal toast, where the bride and groom may kiss each other before leaving the room. In Sweden, there is no large wedding party, but if there is one for each bride and groom, it is one for each. Another tradition is for the bride to place one silver coin from her father in her left shoe and one gold coin from her mother in her right shoe, symbolizing the continuing bond she has with her family.
Swedish wedding dress codes tend to be more relaxed than in the UK, with each wedding being unique. A sixpence, also known as a tanner or sixpenny bit, is a British coin worth six pence, which symbolizes “fidelity and love’s purity.” The color blue is representative of “fidelity and love’s purity” and was also a popular color to wear prior to the white wedding dress trend.
Sweden has its own version of this tradition, where the bride’s mother gives her daughter a gold coin to put in her right shoe before the wedding. The coins symbolize their wish that the bride will never go without money, bringing luck, financial stability, and a sense of family heritage to her married life.
📹 The Wolf of Wall Street – Swiss Bank scene
A clip from the movie “The Wolf of Wall Street” IMDb: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0993846/?ref_=nv_sr_1.
What does it mean if someone puts a penny in your shoe?
We’ve all heard the saying, “find a penny, pick it up, and you’ll have good luck.” This superstition is well known worldwide. Good luck is important on your wedding day, especially for your marriage. A penny in your shoe means wealth and prosperity. Today is Lucky Penny Day, so it’s a good time to talk about this superstition and other wedding day traditions. What do these mean? What are the pros and cons? Knowing this can help you decide which to include on your wedding day. Lucky Penny: Sixpence in Her Shoe. The Middle Ages brought many superstitions. The ‘Lucky Sixpence superstition developed during this time. In the 1600s, the lord of the manor gave his bride a silver sixpence coin as a wedding gift. The coin was later included in the dowry and was thought to bring good luck to the couple. Some families have kept this tradition alive and passed the same sixpence through generations of weddings. If you believe in superstition, this is one of the oldest traditions. It has evolved over the years and is part of some brands. You can find it on products, in your garter, or in your shoe. It’s an easy tradition to follow if you choose to do so! Most of us don’t have a sixpence passed down for generations, but you might want to start one in your family. It’s a fun way to pass down something that will last but still be used.
What is the purpose of the wedding coin?
In Spain, the groom gives his bride a coin after the rings are blessed. The coin shows he’ll share what he has or will have in the future. The bride keeps the coin as a family keepsake. If the couple have children, the bride gives the coin to her eldest son to give to his bride. This tradition is also common in Latin America. In Poland, coins replace confetti. Guests throw coins over the newlyweds as they leave the ceremony. The couple then collect the coins as a symbol of their marriage. A coin is a great gift for a newly married couple. It symbolizes good fortune and unity.
What are Swedish wedding traditions?
4. An old Swedish wedding custom: On her wedding day, the bride carries coins in her shoes. The bride carries coins from her father and mother to ensure she will never go without.
5. Swedish wedding rings: A Swedish bride usually wears three rings: one for her engagement, one for marriage, and one for motherhood.
6. The Swedish bridal bouquet: In Sweden, the bride keeps her bouquet. Wedding customs don’t usually involve throwing it away!
Who pays for the brides shoes?
More brides’ attire. The brides family usually pays for her wedding dress and accessories. This includes the dress, veil, and shoes. Many modern brides pay for their gowns themselves, rather than relying on family.
Grooms attire. The groom’s family usually pays for his attire. But it’s not unusual for the groom to pay for his wedding suit. This cost is usually much less than the wedding gown. If the groom rents his suit, it will be even less.
Groomsmen suits/tuxes. Groomsmen have traditionally paid for their own suits and tuxedos. These items can be expensive, so letting your groomsmen rent their attire is a more affordable option. If your groomsmen rent from the same company, they’ll be coordinated. Read our Groom Fashion blog for more on groomsmen attire.
What coin do you give a bride?
A silver sixpence represents luck and prosperity in marriage! A Silver sixpence in her shoe is something traditionally the father will gift to the bride on her wedding day. It is custom for the father to slip the silver sixpence into the brides heel before she is walked down the aisle.
What does it mean when you put a coin in your shoe?
- A world of tradition. In Great Britain, the bride traditionally wears ‘Something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue. But what is less well known is that the rhyme ends ‘and a silver sixpence in her shoe. For many years, the father of the bride would slip a sixpence into his daughters shoe before she walked down the aisle. The sixpence stood for good luck, and to show that the father wished his daughter prosperity in her marriage.
- Sweden has its own version of this tradition. Before a wedding, the brides mother gives her daughter a gold coin to put in her right shoe. The brides father then gives her a silver coin to put in her left shoe. The coins symbolise their wish that the bride will never go without money.
- In Lithuania, the wedding guests bring silver dollars, half dollars and quarters with them and throw them onto the dance floor. One of the coins is marked with the bride and grooms initials. At the end of the first dance, the wedding guests pick up all the coins for the newlyweds and put them in a clear vase. Whoever picks up the initialled coin gets to have the next dance with either the bride or the groom.
- In Spain and Latin America, the groom gives a coin to his bride after the rings have been blessed. The coin symbolises his willingness to share all that he has or will have in the future. The bride keeps the coin as a family keepsake. If the couple go on to have children, the bride will give the coin to her eldest son to give to his own bride.
- In Poland, instead of confetti, wedding guests throw coins over the married couple after they leave the ceremony. The pair then pick up the coins together as a symbol of their new unity.
- In Great Britain, silver coins are placed into the popped champagne or wine corks and given to the bride and groom as a memento of their special day.
The perfect gift. If youd like to make a long-lasting gift to a newly married couple, a newly minted coin symbolises good fortune and unity. Coins are a memento that the newlyweds can cherish forever. They can pass them down to the next generation.
© The Royal Mint Limited. The Royal Mint Limited is based in the UK (registered in England and Wales No. 06964873).
What is the Swedish wedding coin tradition?
The Swedish coin ceremony is like the British one. The only difference is the gold coin. The mother gives her daughter a gold coin to wear in her shoe, and the father gives her a silver coin. The coins in the shoes are said to ensure the couple will be financially secure.
Why did they throw coins at weddings?
In Scotland and some parts of Northern England, people throw small change onto the ground on the way to the wedding venue. This is called the “Wedding Scramble.” Children would gather around the wedding car just before the bride left. Her father would throw money out as they drove away. This tradition is thought to bring good fortune to the new couple. Nowadays, the groom or the father of the bride throws coins or money after the newlyweds. Another tradition is to put a silver coin from the same year as the wedding in a champagne bottle. The couple can keep it as a memento. This is to wish the couple well. The cork will tighten around the coin, showing the couple’s bond grows.
Worldwide Traditions. In Sweden, the bride is given coins from her parents before the wedding. Her father gives her a silver coin, which she puts in her left shoe. Her mother gives her a gold coin, which she puts in her right shoe. This tradition ensures she will never be financially poor.
What do coins symbolize in marriage?
“The coins were used as a wedding dowry,” says Claudia G. de Velasco, a wedding planner in Houston. Today, the coins symbolize a promise of prosperity and protection in the couple’s marriage. Claudia G. de Velasco is a wedding planner and owner of A Day to Remember and Intimate Celebrations. She is based in Houston, TX, and has planned hundreds of Hispanic weddings in Texas and Mexico. If you want to include the las arras matrimoniales tradition in your Catholic wedding, you may have questions about its history and meaning. Read on to learn more about this tradition and how to incorporate it into your wedding.
What is put into a bride’s shoes for luck in Sweden?
In Sweden, it’s a tradition to put coins in the bride’s shoes to ensure financial success in marriage. The father puts a silver coin on the left foot and the mother puts a gold coin on the right. They wish their daughter happiness in the marriage. However, according to Hindu beliefs, there is a place in hell for those who offend Lakshmi, the goddess of fortune.
The practice comes from Turkey. It’s becoming trendy in Europe. The bride puts the names of single friends on the sole of the shoe. After the dance, the bride takes her wedding shoe and looks at the sole. The name that has been erased most by the wear will be the next to marry. (Photo: Andrew Morrell Photography) Another tradition is to put the names of marriageable friends on a piece of paper inside the right shoe and burn it at the end of the ceremony. This way, friends enter the altar with the bride (on paper). It is said that they can get married within a year.
Why does a bride put a penny in her shoe?
SOMETHING OLD – Back in the day, it was believed that including “Something Old” was the best way to ward off the Evil Eye. However, in modern times it is a lot more light-hearted and often represents to the bride that the wedding is larger than herself. It is often a connection to family or the past and symbolizes the bringing of her family, her past, her traditions through to her future life. One example of this, is taking a piece of fabric from an old wedding dress in the family and sew a small patch into the new dress, veil, or garter.; SOMETHING NEW – While “Something Old” is generally tying the bride to her past, “Something New” is offering the bride hope for her and her partners future. As the new couple is about to enter a whole new chapter in their lives it symbolizes the optimism and hopes for the road ahead. “Something New” can simply refer to the actual union being created with her partner on the day of the wedding. It can also be an item the bride receives from her future partner, her family, her bridal party attendants, or something special she purchases for herself for that day. Many brides Ive worked with have splurged on that just right pair of shoes and called them their “Something New”.; SOMETHING BORROWED – “Something Borrowed” was originally about bringing the new couple good luck and good fertility. The bride would receive or borrow undergarments from a female friend or family member that had a healthy marriage and healthy kids. It was believed that if the bride wore these items, the good luck would follow her into her marriage as well. Nowadays, the same concept is still applied in the sense that many items are someones good luck charm, something from a family member or friend who has a good marriage, or even just something that honors an important person in the brides life.; SOMETHING BLUE – Wearing “Something Blue” was also meant to ward off the Evil Eye as back in the Victoria Era, the color blue represented love, purity, and fidelity. Blue still represents these three things, but it’s no longer the traditional color for wedding gowns. It’s used in other ways. Many clients find ways to incorporate blue by having their garter, necklace, or bouquet include blue flowers. Some clients use blue for the wedding party, bouquets, and boutonnieres as their “something blue.” This is so everyone is part of it. A SIXPENCE IN YOUR SHOE – This part of the rhyme is simple. In Victorian England, the bride was given a sixpence coin to put in her shoe for good luck. Brides carried coins into their weddings to attract wealth. It was thought to be most effective if their fathers placed them in their shoes. Today, brides often use a penny instead of a sixpence coin. This tradition is often more light-hearted than its original meaning. If you want to honor tradition, follow it with a twist or are superstitious, you might have a lifetime of wealth if you put a penny in your shoe.
Want more ideas to make your big day special? Our event specialists can help you add a unique twist to any wedding tradition.
📹 Europe’s Problem With The Roma
The Romani people have been a part of European culture for centuries — Charlie Chaplin and flamenco both have Romani …
To clarify, this is not laundering, it’s simply tax evasion. He is hiding his money in a swiss bank rather than keeping it in an american one or his house where the IRS can ask questions about where it came from. He then can launder the money which means to make it taxable (Ex. buying a business and giving yourself a massive fake salary which comes from the illegal money). In this case though Jordans money isn’t illegal like a drug dealers, he just doesnt want to pay tax so he wouldnt need to launder it.
This movie’s ensemble cast is freaking great. Tons of supporting actors made very little screentime yet they all managed to stole the show in just about any scene that they’re in. Genius writing for their characters and incredible acting, I can’t think of a single actor being wasted in this masterpiece
I have been perusal several articles for several hours from from different sources, it has been confusing to know if im catching up with the information that im required to be watched from the same staff, because i get this article as it has been some sort of misinterpretation, stressful and confusing will be back here by noon, apologies for it, thank you for your understanding
Single safe haven approaches are not an adequate risk avoidance strategy. Due to the singular point of failure in the advent of policy shifts far better to setup a legal proxy and diversify the assets to a diverse set of safe havens all optimized for the assets and liabilities arising. In no instance would I deal in a singular point of contact when a far better proxy optimized system could easily be setup. Also the concept of physically transporting fiat across borders is a retarded approach when I could simply utilize a proxy of cryptocurrencies and convert to fiat as needed. This scene just indicates how much has changed in the last two decades. I have my favorite safe havens and Switzerland is not my favorite due to the interlinkage with the EU members. The data privacy laws are not adequate due to agency and third party nation state policies
To add, if you own a food store and someone buys a sandwich and a soda, you don’t how the person obtained the cash they are paying you with. Maybe they stole it from their granny, maybe they performed honest labor for it, your only real concern is that the money they give you isn’t counterfeit. How is depositing cash in a bank any different?.
Anybody have advice on how to speak telepathically, or whatever Belfort and Mr. Swizz dick are doing @ 1:24-1:29? I just think that would be so awesome like sitting in a restaurant and doing that with my friend or girlfriend lol then maybe I could tell the waiter to brng the check if they are connected telepathical wise. But yeah, or maybe its not real and they added to the movie to make it very cool.
Why make the assumption that the other is dirty? The banker doesn’t know exactly how Jordan obtained his cash and the bank seemed very legitimate. You are considered as a matter of law and practical politeness innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. There are corrupt prosecutors who will go after innocent people just to make a name for themselves.
Hi. These events should sound familiar I submitted them years ago from 2002- via email, letter,etc the devil’s case . The movies based on true events t most of them I remember your best lawyers,invistigfators,etc. Looked into it the result was near billions with lawyers fees out. Etc the final result was still in the millions you guys did a great job . I remember the cia,fbi,etc were all involved for best results and protection. I was living in neveda at the time or out of state normally I was in cali,nv,ny,etc I will tell u the best way I can . I have attached the movies,pics,etc related to this case. Or what I’m writing to you these ppl are scary still are some are in jail, state, federal prison,etc the reasons everything from sex trafficking, trafficking,assault,robbery,etc all over the world . So I have had many jobs agencies,qsr, sales,etc like 20 . Various fields. I got involved with mlm back in 2003- worked with many networkers Tim herr, hayden daughters now bjorn . Frank ching,Andy chau, danny bae, Michael sejun an, George zakucki,etc I started in the irvine office the president’s there were Jim rohn, Jerry ballah,Tim herr, pat johnston,danny bae,etc I then got sent to neveda to expand . I did for 10 or more hrs daily 6 days my first year was near $10 million in sales and svp/ president seat and coc. #1 producer under ballah rohn . Also repeated the same in 5links 5linx . Former acn was Andre maronian from 1996 to 2006. All big time ballers in my opinion. Some of them are still in acn some revital u some 5linx and others.
this scene is legendary, Martin Scorsese is basically explaining how all the greedy rich people store their massive amounts of wealth overseas to Switzerland instead of giving money to their underpaid employees, contractors, and overall community. The whole point of money is to be a medium of exchange but if giant amounts of money aren’t being used at all, its essentially the same thing as having no money at all. This scene was awesome but i feel like burning the swiss people alive for giving the methods to make this happen.
my ex prime minister embezzled public funds and they are in a Swiss acount. The public ministery (the defender of the portuguese state) asked Switzerland for the informations of the accounts. its clear what they did, isnt it? without that evidence, and by pulling strings in the supreme court, the former prime minister got a judge who was extremely favorable to him. At the trial, the judge dropped all 30 corruption crimes because there was “not enough evidence” and because “the crimes have already expired”. Therefore, the former prime minister did an interview laughing at the Portuguese while drinking a beer in a coastal village for rich people.
This movie is very informative. It shows us how the capitalism works: more, more, more! Belfort is the personification of the capitalism. More money, drugs and xxx, this is what our system needs: exceeding every limits. He became so rich because of us, the 99%. We want to be also rich and this is why we buy these worthless stocks. I love “The Big Short” as well. Both movies show us in a different way how the economics work.
My mum is a teacher and had a Romani student that did really well at school, wanted to pursue higher education, but was shunned by his family and friends for that. It must be really difficult because if you stand out it’s easy to feel like you don’t belong anywhere. People must have shunned him in the dominant culture because he was Romani, and the Romani shunned him for following the “mainstream” ways. I can see why in such cases the easiest path is for the status quo to remain.
I’m not Romani, I’m Hmong, but their history is really similar to our history. Our people migrated around a lot because of persecution and annexation. Started in China and settled all over South East Asia. Most of our people died building The Great Wall and kept in slavery for a long time. Still no reparations to this day because they’re trying to erase our history. The only way one would know is story passed on down by their families.
My only contact with Romani was in Italy at a tourist spot. A mother—( or captain?) had a group of five children rush me. Their hands were in my pockets and my jacket ( I use a money belt when I travel). I had no idea what was happening, and I pushed them away hard enough to make one fall over. I screamed bloody hell at the woman, which I am able to do at an extremely high volume. And still they persisted. I was in shock. I had never experienced anything remotely like it. What on earth am I supposed to think?
All I can say is I was a restaurant manager and every single time gypsies came in we had a problem. Not 1 or 2 times, but 16 for 16 100%. And it was the same thing every time, customize everything then complain that thats not what was on the menu, then eat 80% of the food then try to send it back and get a refund, then when I wouldn’t give it to them they would throw stuff on the floor and threaten my staff.
From what I gather, this hate is because people do not have good personal experiences with the romas. You can keep an open mind, but if you get robbed, scammed, thrown rocks at, trash your neighborhood every time you actually interact with them, then you’ll develop your own perceptions due to that experience.
My take on the whole situation with the Roma people as doctor working in a public hospital in Bulgaria, where a good amount of the patients are Romani is that a big problem for them is their clan structure. Almost all of the ones that are living in poverty belong to something like a clan run by a criminal boss( we call it a gypsy baron) who is responsible for the “well being” of his subjects – forbids them to be educated in order to keep the status quo, forces them to work criminal jobs like prostitution or begging and most importantly collects money from political parties during election and orders his people who to vote for – that’s why this system is tolerated. I didn’t see anything meaningful in this article how to integrate the Roma, just raising some awareness. A good example for Roma people that broke off from this system in Bulgaria are the ones that joined religious sects, like seventh day Adventists. They are usually educated and don’t live in poverty, so maybe that’s one way.
When I was a kid (in England), travellers moved into the local field behind our housing area. I can’t recall if they were Irish travellers or Romani, but they pitched themselves on the land with their caravans. I always hung out with the kids in the local area and most of us have never encountered ‘travellers’ before. The first time we met with the kids from the travellers, one of the boys pulled out a knife on us for no apparent reason. From that point on, the negative view of travellers has stuck with me. They just move on to public land, leave tons of trash and shit everywhere and move on. The local council decided to dig trenches around the fields to prevent them from pitching on the land.
Situation from Serbia: My sister had in her class a Roma girl, with great grades, who wanted to become a doctor. But her grandfather arranged her a marriage to a guy that 10 years older and lived in Austria. Her father could not stand to his father. She was 14. Many Roma children are born at home. And these births are never reported, so they have no ID. And when these children have children of their own, they could not be reported as their mother did not have an ID. They could not travel, go to school, doctor. They do not exist. Some even do not know when or where they are born. Problem is that if they want to join surrounding society, they are banished from Roma. But there is a fear that other would not accept them, so they become alone. PS. When I got to university I was so happy to see Roma-looking guy. But it turned out, it was a student from Bangladesh.
A romani tried to pickpocket me once using a kid as he distracted me. I’m not one for violence but when I felt a hand in my pocket from behind my first instinct was a immediate elbow straight back. Into a 10 year old gypsies face. I smacked the kid hard as he was stunned and then got punched by the romani man. And then he discovered what a specifically sharpened key to the throat felt like when I stabbed him with one.
I was always friends with Roma since I was a child I had two best friends in my class we would spend everyday together then one of them disappeared. We later found out she was sold by her family to be married she was 9. My other best friend disappeared at 11 also sold to a man. As I grew up I witnessed so many disgusting things that the Roma did they would have so many children that the children themselves didn’t know their names bcs they never got named. After my friends were sold I stayed away from Roma people in my city. I know there are those who live normal lives and I respect them but those who still follow their traditions so closely they sell their own daughters as children disgust me and no matter what I can’t see past that.
As an American As far as I know there’s only one family of Romani in my area. The dad pretends to be Mexican and plays the accordion while panhandling and the mom stands in a parking lot asking for money with her school age children with her to make people sympathetic, instead of sending them to school so they can live better lives. One time I witnessed the mom try to distract a shopkeeper while her daughter made a pass at some jewelry
In Lithuania we had a big problem were we were trying to integrate Roma people into our society, but it was hard for them to keep children in school, especially girls. And then without education the poverty circle kept going, so Roma people made a living selling drugs in their village outside of the city. A few years ago social housing was provided for Roma people in different parts of town to encourage integration into general society. I hope that with these measures they can integrate well and have the social support needed to keep children in schools. Last year we had a first Roma restaurant open in the capital and it’s doing pretty well.
I really don’t wanna be “that” guy but in my country in my neighbourhood there’s a strong romani gypsy community and has sprawled quite alot, they probably make about 10% of my city population due to the high amount of kids they get, and i really wish i had good things to say about them, but i don’t, i’ve spent my whole life in one way or another trying to avoid really the gypsies in my neighbourhood since i’ve moved here in 1998, i was 8 at the time and here’s some stories i’ve heard of what romani people do and or have done here. Romani teens couldnt go to school so they’d catch kids who they knew had rich parents, and pointed knifes at their chins asking for all the money they had in their pockets ( back then you could tell who the rich kids were if they had a cellphone ). Romani women were loud and obnoxious in many service areas, they’d jump the line and half of them would be pregnant all the time and they would use the excuse of being 8 month pregnant to skip the lines. Romani men are almoust never admitted to work in production lines or wharehouses even construction work, i’ve worked in similar places and according to my experience there they are rarely given a job because they arrive late, some days don’t arrive at all, and always ask for more money and or more benefits. Romani teens here were known for distributing drugs mostly weed at that time when it was still illegal in my country and they’d hand it over to their younger brothers to give it to older teens who came from middle income, many a times these young romani kids would sport knifes and threatened to stab other teens if they refused to buy it.
I’m from Europe, and I’ll say that, whilst it’s sad, stereotypes exist from a reason and they don’t come from nowhere. We’ve had problems in the past with train cancellations on the main lines due to gypsies stealing the metal from the tracks and copper out of the wires. Gypsy camps are notorious as places of violence, and when they’re out they’re infamous for acting like complete arseholes for no reason – verbally abusing folks for no reason. They often pitch up in fields, on grass verges, and leave a huge mess, they have no respect for the land they’re usually illegally camping on, and are a major headache for the farmer if they decide to use one of his fields, one of our Conservative MPs even called them “scum” in 2002 in regards to the nightmare they had caused his constituency. About a decade ago, my country had a very low opinion of Romanians because Romanians were rare in our country back then, and the only exposure must of us had had to “Romanians” were violent gypsies from Romania who called themselves “Roma”, leading many to assume all Romanians must be like that, fortunately more genuine Romanians have arrived since.
Unfortunately it takes two to tango and governments have given the Roma plenty of chances to participate in society but they seem to blow it too often. Students leaving school despite having good grades, houses given for free only to be trashed, jobs organised and turned down etc. If they don’t want to help themselves then they can’t complain.
As an Italian who has had a terrible experience with Romani people (mugged once, scammed, and threatened), I personally stopped giving a crap about the Romani. I have tried being positive and kind to them, but something about their culture is absolutely atrocious. It’s like even when I try being honest with them and try giving them a hand by giving fresh fruit or a bottle of water to them whenever I do encounter them in my local park, they just give me a weird look and sometimes tell me to leave. Ever since I got mugged by one of them for 11 lousy euros, I just stopped giving and stop caring for them. You may think only a small percentage of people in Europe hate them and discriminate against them, but the truth is that almost every European absolutely openly despises them, including me now.
There indeed is a big stigma about them in Europe. The sad thing is that where I live (Paris, France), the only contact we have with them is through human trafficked children scamming and stealing not to be beaten up going back at their camp. Or beggars. There are scandals every year about dismantled traffics. So besides european racism they also are hard within the community.
I’ve interacted with Roma exactly six times that I know of, and in three different countries. All six encounters shared one unifying feature. Petty crime. In four interactions, the Roma stole or were stealing something from me or someone else. In two, they were actively scamming people. I don’t like to generalize about any group based on the actions of such a small sample, but it’s hard for me to see the Roma in any other way.
Racial discrimination is not an American or European or African problem. It’s an integrated human problem. When you have a large group that holds power and wealth you subjugate or put down those that are different because they see themselves as superior. I wouldn’t be surprised if Neantrathals met a similar end when they met our ancestors.
I thought I didn’t judge people by their heritage, culture, religion, race, until I got to know the Roma people in various countries around Europe. Initially I was one of the people who got in to verbal arguments with people that “we should never judge any people because of their….” when I heard people talking ill of the Roma people which I didn’t know of, but did eventually. Am sure there are good Roma people, but 99.9% of the Roma people I have come across has deeply depressed and upset me. How vulgar and uncultured (outside their culture, which is where they choose to live but not follow the law of the lands) they can be and how proud they are of it. The woman in the interview should point out how many social, education, labor programs there are in most European countries of which they just do not take advantage and how this leads to discrimination. Why does she not explain how the Roma people pass their children around to different mothers in different streets to beg to ultimately hand this money over to papa Roma guy? Give them more power? What? How about starting the change from the family unit and work the way out and up? Am sorry. But it’s the truth from my experience.
I’d like to see myself as an open and understanding person, always trying to give people a chance. As a Swede I have had only a few encounters with Romani people. And every time has just been worse than the one before. Never in my life have I met more racist and homophopic people, calling both white and black people names, un-pure and other disguisting things. I have only personally experienced shoplifting twice, both times Romani people. As a gay man, I have been very lucky in my life. Sweden is a great place to live for HBTQ+ people like myself. I have only been harassed like three times in my life (for being gay). Which is a low number compared to other homosexual people that I know. And the worst encounter was again, with Romani. When they found out about me having a boyfriend, not only did my bike get stolen “randomly” the day after. But they gave me dirty looks, refused to be near me etc. Maybe I have had unlucky experiences sure, but most of the stereotypes about them seem to be true. And I will never understand, nor will I never respect the Romani people for that. That’s just my honest opinion.
I can say a thing or two about the Bulgarian Integration plan. Speaking from direct experience, it’s not rooted in racism. It attempts to integrate Roma people in normal society by providing work opportunities, education and improving the standard of living. A lot of schools here are so low in students that the teachers literally go from door to door and beg Roma parents to send there children to school. Even the free abortion thing is done not to limit the number of Roma but because a lot of underage girls leave school when they become pregnant. There are also contraception and vaccination campaigns being done with the help of health mediators. Most of the time these mediators are Roma themselves. Granted your average Bulgarian feels and says a bunch of racist things about the Roma people, but I can assure you the integration program is really trying to help these people improve their lives and become part of society. I don’t believe it’s succeeding much but it is trying.
I went to the Haunted Mansion in Disneyland, France one a while back. As we entered elevator room, a family of Romanis with about 12 or so childeren entered as well. As soon as the lights went out, I could feel all the children trying to get their hands in my pocket, while my fiance-now wife tried to fight off hands that were trying to get into her purse. Even outside of Disneyland, I had a problem with people which look like Romanis bumping into us, trying to pick our pockets, or sending swarms of kids on us to get something. You can see why people are on guard whenever Romanis are present. It’s not racism, it’s simply just pattern recognizing and reaction. People are conditioned to be wary of Romani presence, or get their stuff stolen. They’re also not doing a very good job dispelling this image either.
This report falls into the cliché of presenting the discrimination of Gipsies as something completely inexplicable. It doesn’t make the slightest attempt to explain why Gipsies are hated or disliked in so many places. Quite a few Roma have integrated and are now indistinguishable for ‘payos’ – as Gipsies call everyone else, in Spain. But Roma living in Gipsie-majority communities make terrible neighbours. They refuse to follow laws and common-sense rules; and are often ready to resort to violence if they are called-out. Plus many of them engage in drug traffic, robbery, extortion and similar low-profile crimes.
This is so far from reality. I have lived in Poland and witnessed Roma communities, the reality is, there is no „racism”. They dont let their kids go/stay in school, steal, break in houses, get in fights, insult people in Poland. I never had a good interaction with any Roma, so shut up about „racism”, they earned the respect they have.
It is common that when we talk about the Roma, in Spain, where I live, racist comments and prejudices are part of the conversation. However, this mini documentary has overlooked something that happens in Spain and according to the comment section of this article, it also happens in other countries and that is that the Spanish government has been giving educational aid to this ethnic group for years to promote studies among them, however, the vast majority of them abandon their studies around the age of 14, especially women who are married and forced to maintain their virginity until marriage so as not to be a “disgrace to their family and their culture” . The lack of education means that they have to work in precarious jobs and many end up in the drug business, occupying other people’s houses and stealing. And the truth is that people in general turn away from people who lead this kind of life, whether they are Roma or not, but the fact that most of them are in some way pressured to follow this kind of life for the sake of “following their culture and traditions”, prevents greater harmony between this ethnic group and the rest of Spain. However, it is true that in recent years some Roma families have allowed their children to finish their secondary education and some even pursue university studies, unfortunately they are the 1% of their population and these are usually men, but I have had the pleasure to meet and become friends with some of them.
It is a two-way problem. There are a lot of government programs in Europe for integration of the gypsies. But they fail as there is a deep mismatch with the culture of these people. The core problem is their clan based society structure. They stick with their own. In every East European city you can find one or several areas entirely populated by Roma. And it is not because they are forced to live there – it is what their culture is. On a very rare occasion you will see a gypsy family living out of these “gheto”s and the general rule is that these are doctors, teachers, engineers etc. Overall, people that made their choice to integrate themselves into the society. In Bulgaria e.g. the social payments law has been changed with the single purpose to force the Romani parents to send kids to school at least to 8th grade. The condition of receiving child benefits was to have your children going to school. Plus part of the social support has been issued in products – cooking oil, flower, rice, pasta etc. simply due to the fact that many Roma families live on benefits and the cash they receive is either turned into alcohol, drugs, being gambled out or taken by the community “baron” because of loans. Do not get me wrong – not all gypsies are like this. It all depends on what clan they belong.
Im so tired of this “racism” word being thrown around when we talk about gypsies. Most of us are not racist, but living a lifetime around them made us learn to keep our pockets safe, because if you will be stolen from in Europe, it will be a gypsy 99.99% of times. Im from Romania, where we have the biggest population of gypsies and life is not pleasant around them, to be fair. Im lucky to have a gypsy community in my village that is more civilized and got integrated well with the rest, but you still have your weekly fight and police visit. The thing only gets worse when you go to bigger towns and cities, pickpockets and scammers are everywhere, all gypsy. You can also read comments from different countries like France or Germany, where many migrated from Romania after joining EU, the stories said there are not hood either. Most countries tried to integrate them, but is so hard when their culture is so full of anti-social behavior.
They came to the European continent several centuries ago and never became integrated into any European countries, they’ve never been willing to. If all the native Europeans think the same about them, there must be a well-grounded reason for that, the responsability can’t rest on the whites just because they are assumed to be racist. The responsability also rests on the gypsies themselves and their behaviors in the societies with which they co-exist. The woke classic perspective imported to Europe and aloof from the real European experiences and perspectives.
I live 100 meters away from the biggest population of Roma people in spain and I can tell you from my own experience that the Roma people can be very nice but you also need to look out with them. How much I see them pickpocket, intimitade people, fighting, throwing trash where ever they go etc. They do not allow any “White” spanish person in their circle unless you are from the goverment or NGO and you have something that helps them or is “free” etc. I have a good friend who is Roma and he is very succesful but he himself said that they are very close minded people and education is not the main priority in their culture. He tried once to have a “White” spanish girlfriend and told his mom and she said she can never be part of the family and better not to tell the rest. All in all not everything is done well by the goverment here at all regarding this ethnic group but the group itself needs to be willing to integrate as well.
We used to have a family of Rom come into the grocery store I worked at and we knew they were stealing and scamming the cashiers by manipulating the kind of change they wanted. Eventually the store owner had enough. He had 2 security guys follow them around when they came in, and stand like 5 feet away from them at all times and watch them like hawks. When they got to the check out line, a cart filled with 10 25lbs bags of dog food was pushed behind them, one guard took up position at the door and the other held the dog food cart in place . So they were essentially trapped in the check out lane. The cashier turned off her light and the store manager was called over and put in a fresh till with barely any cash in it and took over the register for their transaction. They were told they would be checked out, and if they even asked for any alteration on the order or their change or presented any of their clearly fake coupons, they would be detained in the security office, the police called, they could sort it out with them and then they would be perma-banned from the store. After the 3rd time of this we never saw them there again. They showed up about 6 months later in the news when the cops busted them for drug trafficking and dog fighting.
Well back in Portugal the gypsies had a lot of criminals, I was in service and one of our man was stabbed by a gypsie and ended badly for all of them when 2 trucks of paratroopers came to their camping site and beat the shit of everyone and burned everything. Not talking about when I was a teenager and had to fight a few during my time I lived in an area bordering a “bairro” of gypsies. Today we have then coming from Romania pocket picking in Lisbon, Porto and Algarve. So no good memories from them and so far I don’t see them trying to integrate in our society.
This article is just telling one side of the stroy. I’ve grown up in a working class neighberhood in Bulgaria with mixed Bulgarian and Gypsy population. I’ve grown up and played with gypsies. By no way, shape or form I think gypsies are bad people or anything of the sort. A lot of them want a higher education and honest jobs, but also a lot of them: – need to be forced by the government to send their kids to school and still don’t; – child brides; – have build gypsy communities on land they never bought and are not paying any taxes for, and when the government wants to use the land IT OWNS the gypsy communities start calling it represion and are left alone with free land; – those communities have horrible living conditions brought upon by the gypsies themselves by burning tires and throwing garbage not in dumps but just all around their own community; – refuse to take jobs with official contracts, because they don’t want to pay the taxes ( in all honesty a lot of Bulgarians do that ); – have huge numbers of kids without having any way of supporting them and then complain that the government should be giving them MORE free benefits because their children have nothing to eat. Those benefits by the way are payed by taxes, – most gypsies have payed little to no taxes in their lives; – there are cases where the government build apartment buildings and gave them for free to gypsies to live in, within a year or two the buildings were mostly torn apart by the gypsies for the free scrap, oh and kept farm animals within the buildings; – most begger schemes, small theft/shoplifting and a large portion of prostitution is run by gypsy “lords”, – I know 2 guys that have physically attacked a gypsy, but I know literelly at least 10 that have been physycally attacked by gypsys, including multiple cases of sexual abuse.
Sigh Anyone else just… confused and overwhelmed with mixed emotions about Romani people? On one hand i dont want to generalize them as just “bad people” just because of their ethnicity, but on the other hand a lot of people had negative experiences with them including myself, but Romani dont seem to want to change. Should we help them? Educate them? Maybe, that would be nice, but who is going to do all of that, and how? The people who hate them do have a decently good point: Romani have made a pretty bad name for themselves so that makes it pretty hard to help them. It doesnt help that whenever these people commit crimes in an X country, the news are usually along the lines “Person from X country did crime”, and so if you are actually from that country it doesnt feel fair to be associated with the Romani people. And so the cycle begins: Romani did bad thing in X, X people gain bad reputation for something they didnt do, so then X people hate Romani. So you can see how this is just a complicated mess to solve. The easy and obvious answer is “Be the better person and try to help Romani people”, but unfortunately not all people are that nice, which is understandable, it doesnt feel fair to instantly accept someone who did horrible things to you. And im over here stuck in the middle of this unable to form a proper opinion, with both anger and pity, two very different emotions, fighting in my brain.
In the village I grew up, there were like 70% roma people and 30% romanians. All i can say is that the roma people had never been discriminated or subjugated by romanians. Even in the school, there were many opportunities that favorized the roma people and defavorized romanians. For example, when going to high school, roma people had reserved places and the grades in the exam didn t even matter, but romanians had to hard learn. Also, romanians in the village never discriminated the roma people. Instead, roma people were always blaming romanians for different reasons. The roma children terrorized old romanian people, verbally abusing them and even destroying their gardens and fences. And the roma people were throwing the trash in the street as a daily basic activity. I tried to explain to some of them that the place of the trash is in the dumbster, but they were laughing at me saying that i am a “fool”. So, I just want to share my experiences with the roma people. I m not racis and never have been, i believe in the equality of races. At least in Romania, they are priviliged, not discriminated.
I visited Europe and helped with some charity events. At one event we were feeding kids in attendance. They would line up and we would give them box lunches. I and others noticed that some of the kids would re-enter the line to get more meals. This meant that other kids might not get their meal. All of those trying to get a second meal were Roma kids. The stereotype of Gypsies being thieves is based on personal experiences. It wasn’t just made up.
I live in Greece where there have been numerous attempts to integrate the Roma in society. In the primary school I went into, any other group (of which there were many, besides Greeks) had to find a way to get there, but for the Roma kids there where big state paid busses for just a couple of children, mainly girls. After Christmas holidays, these children magically disappeared from school and I later found out the government paid they parents to send them to school. If my mom didn’t send me and my brother to school, the child protected services will be called. That’s just an example to show how differently they have been treated by the government, giving them housing and funds, only for them to steal, sell drugs and mainly harass other people in the community, verbally of physical. I always try to be empathetic and not fall for stereotypes but the cherry on top for me was the statement by the leader of the Roma community about the lockdown: “How are we supposed to steal now?” -that’s a real statement, look it up
Watching this as a Slovak, this article feels completely disconnected from reality. Sure, there are real racists among us, but I believe I’m speaking for most of us here that we are not racist, we just see how most of these people behave and we’ve learned how to behave accordingly. If 95% of people you’ve ever met from some community are vulgar, inadaptable and stinky people from a nearby ghetto and you’ve often seen them take drugs and always cause mess, it’s perfectly normal to expect it from the next person of this community you meet too. Of course, there are racist idiots who will meet a well-dressed, classy and clearly educated Romani person somewhere in a bank and they’ll look down on him anyway but those are just an extremist minority of the population that won’t be helped by perusal articles like these.
Did an experiment once, a gypsy asked me for money, said she has no job and no way to support her kids so i offered her some food, she took it and threw it away when she thought i do not see her. Worse, she just threw it on the ground, just like that, not in a trash can. In my opinion, the fact that they are discriminated is the normal and logical reaction. We, as humanity and as a civilization are evolving and growing and almost every culture in the world is growing accordingly but the roma people seem to want to live in medieval conditions. They are not poor, they just want to make us think that. Many adult gypsies like to flash their wealth so everybody can see what car they drive or what a big house they have and the gold they wear around their necks and the big pile of cash they have when going groceries shopping. All this while none of them have a job, nor pay any kind of taxes and all of them apply and get social aid from the state. Do you know why they have many children…..it’s because the state gives them social aid for every child they have. They are discriminated because they deserve to be discriminated, they bring no value to the societies that they live in, no contribution of any kind, in fact precious resourcers are wasted on them in the hope they will better themselves but they just take everything and continue with their way of life. They do not want to tend school, they do not want to work, they just want to live their parasitic lives. At least this is how the situation is in Romania, and i am sure there are exceptions within the roma people whom have evolved past all that, but they are just a drop of water in a lake.
Live in Sweden and remember when many years ago I saw a Roma family outside a department store, helped the woman put on a Roma dress (such a big and wide one) and saw how they fixed the hook in it (a lot of things got lost in it the store that day).\r In the neighboring village, a Finnish Swede had a store, she has told that once a family of Roma came in and how the Roma woman, who was the mother, told her adult sons to steal as much as possible while she herself kept the woman in the till. The mother said this in Finnish, not knowing that the shop owner was Finnish. Of course they yelled that she was racist when she kicked them out.
I’m not sure it’s about racism. Back when I was a kid i remember my parents runned a shoes and clothings shop not far from a big and often empty parking area. There sometimes roma’s groups stopped for a bit and then many of them could start to be seen around the village. Everytime a Roma entered my parents shop they had to keep an eye on them just to be sure nothing was going to be stolen, and every single time they caught them trying to leave the shop without paying. I’m not saying other customers never tried to steal, but not in the 100% of the cases. I must add: this is probably racism but I’m sure that if they payed for what they wanted my parents would have been 100% glad to have them around. To sum up their ideology “as long as it pays, customer is always right”, so I’m not sure it’s really about racism
While there is a lot of racism going towards the rroma community, to be fair, on the ground the situation is not so simple. Growing up and living all my life near one of the largest gypsy communities in Eastern Europe, Gârcini, in the Romanian county of Brașov, I can tell you from my own life-long experience that people that are part of the gypsy community are also the people that are most likely to exhibit anti-social behaviour. For starters, very often you see them playing loud music (manele in 99% of the times) on the bus, eating sun flower seeds and just littering the bus floor, throwing trash right out on the streets, and generally making a lot of mess. They also have a tendency to be violent, not rarely I’ve seen them randomly breaking things like street signs, benches, street recycle bins etc. Also, the two times I got beaten up in my 22 years of life, were by some members of a kinda-notorious gypsy family/clan, with whom I had absolutely no bussines with, they just came up to me and starting harassing me, then started beating me up without stealing anything from me. They just did it because they could… and I do know alot of similar cases. While I am not racist, at all, I cannot deny the reality. I kind of understand why this kind of anti-social behavior is so often encountered in the rroma community. Due to centuries of oppression from white folks, they formed a culture around opposing what we normally see as ‘civilization’, maybe because they collectively associate it with said oppression, and the state is surely not helping at all.
This article did not touch on the real issue of why Roma people are looked down upon. The reason is the way they are visible and behave in European cities: Beggars and thieves who leave faeces everywhere, argue and fight loudly and can litter a park in no time. And it is especially older ladies who are their victims of aggressive begging and theft. When I lived and worked in central Oslo, I had to intervene several times. If an old lady gave some money to a Roma woman, she could be embraced by a whole crowd who put their hands in the old woman’s pockets. And if they lured an elderly lady into a kiosk to buy them a coffee, they gave the confused woman a shopping cart and put it full of goods before they got to the checkout. Yes, this is probably unfair to most Roma people. But at the same time, it’s the real reason why the Roma people are looked down upon.
It’s not possible to solve the problem of discrimination and persecution by only portraying them as victims. Those who are seen as “problematic” and criminal are those who live in parallel societies, with internal laws and norms which crashes with their surrounding society. Let’s be honest, some Romani are stigmatized as thieves, beggars, scammers, squatters and as posing a hygienic health risk by what people experience. Unless they are willing to really take effective measures to combat those aspects of those parts of Romani culture, they will never lose their stigma of being problematic, and will never be regarded as fully citizens of their host countries. You can not demand that racism and discrimination should magically seize to exist, not without making any effort to weed out the troubling aspects of your culture. Like it or not, but as a species we’re hardwired to discriminate and stereotype.
When I lived in Germany I met a number of “Sigoyners” and every time the interaction was not positive. They have tried to cheat me, rob me, or inflict violence on me on several occasions. As someone of African descent, I can empathize with being the subject of racism, but much of the hatred that Roma people get today is their own fault.
The article fails to present the reasons of this discrimination towards gypsies. They are very often associated with crimes and they choose to remain outside the society. For example in Greece, there was a huge wave of immigrants coming from Albania during the 90’s. While in the beginning they were met with discrimination eventually they were fully integrated into the Greek society. They went to school, they worked, they opened business etc. Gypsies on the other hand never tried to become part of the society.
In Spain my experience is different. There were given nice apartments for free in nice neighborhood. Brand new with everything…weeks later they had sold every applicance, pipe and went to the street and put fires and cooked there. They said they like freedom. They sell cheap clothing in the weekly markets but no more work either. I’m sorry. They like living for free damage all, steal, sell drugs…that is my experience after 40 years in spain and living in the same neighborhood with the ones born and raised in spain. The ones coming from Romania…dress terrible put kids to beg, offer you money for sex with them outside a business, school,…they have big skirts and they just pooped anywhere under those skirts. They trick you with the romero for money and if you refuse, they yell and become violent forcing you the romero outside mercadona or any other grocery store.
“That white Europeans don’t have the moral responsibility to do something….” This is disingenuous, dishonest and false. Europe has given housing, education, and spent, and spent and spent. But can the EU force a Roma mother to read to her child? To pick up a mop and scrub her floor? What do the Roma actually want that has not been given?
Great article, but you left out the parts where NUMEROUS nations have had programs to integrate their Romani populations, the partial successes and the numerous failures. Before moving to Europe I had nothing but open mindedness towards the Romani. Having lived here for a while, I have little patience left.
The gypsy problem, at least here in the Balkans, is that the governments do/did try a lot of times to integrate the societies into the country’s society (by offering apartments for free, help in education, including giving free points for university enrollment) and ultimately failed in it. However this whole process has a lot of problems and rabbit holes that it’s not really simple. Many births aren’t reported and hence the children don’t “exist” and hence don’t have the paperwork/ID/health insurance. There is a large stigma towards Roma who try to educate themselves and very often get no support from their family and because of that you can’t really educated a Roma child if it “doesn’t exist” and their parents don’t WANT the child educated. The parent in this situation decides if their kid will go to school or not even though it is punishable by law if you don’t give your child elementary education, however, you can’t punish someone who doesn’t exist. Society doesn’t even help the situation either, with a decent minority, many of Roma are decent and educated members of society, however a vast majority doesn’t even integrate. They tend to do criminal activity like theft (money, metals, they also tend to illegally connect to electricity, water, sewage etc) and drug dealing BUT also they don’t integrate well with society, they tend to be very filthy, they tend to cause unrest in apartment buildings, they also beg and most people don’t have a high opinion of them because of all this negative experience from a majority of a community.
When I was younger I met a Romani guy while playing Magic the Gathering. He was a really quiet guy but eventually he started talking about his past. About how he’d lived in Hungary from birth to 17 and yet was not a Hungarian citizen. About how many of his family members had been killed just for existing. About how grateful he felt about becoming an American citizen after his military service. 😥 Imagine being a stateless person who has been treated like a sub-human your whole life. He was “lucky” because he was able to leave but Romani people shouldn’t have to leave their home countries to be treated like human beings. People always suggest leaving but that is not a viable solution for most Romani people. It costs money to pull up roots to start over and the bigger price is being torn from an existing support system. I saw a comment here saying that Romani people should return to India and just…no. They left over 1,500 years ago and have no link other than genetics and vague linguistic clues to India. Pushing minorities out is what morally weak societies like to do because it’s less internal labor than acknowledging past wrongs and moving forward with new information and a dedication to anti-racism.
As a European (and this still sounds racist) – there’s a huge difference between pattern recognition and racism. Americans don’t like other races because they look / smell different and because their parents raise them that way. In Europe we don’t care about your skin color or smell. We care about how you and your people act. If 90% of interactions you’ve had with a certain group are bad, chances are high you’re not gonna like the group. There’s a big difference between blatant racism and negative prejudice based on actual real life experiences you’ve made YOURSELF instead of just being told about by parents and friends. But I wouldn’t expect any American to understand this. Also what’s said in the article: Europeans need to do something against racial imbalances and the nomadic life-style of the Romani – like – no girl. Most Romani do not pursue higher education, leading to them not getting a lot of monetary compensation for their work if they decide to do so. They are making their own integration as hard as possible and now blame it on other races. This shit mag fly in America but not over here. Actions have consequences.
Its beyond economic factors, its what they do. When I was an Intern at a police department we had roma gangs coming directly from europe to where we were specifically to steal things from department stores. How that makes sense monetarily, the price for tickets, housing, cost of living since they cant work on those visas etc to steal earbuds and android tablets was beyond me. When we asked one of them why they were willing to travel all this way to steal $200 worth of stuff she said “this is what I do”. Then when I started traveling every country I went to it was a roma running a scam. soliciting donations for fake charities, money exchange scams, ticket scams, every scam you can think of ran by them, in every city. Does every roma steal? no, but an unbelievably large amount of them do.
I meet a guy who was in the Spanish military a few years ago. He compared them to locusts and felt Europe would be better off if they were wiped out. He said in Spain that a majority of their criminals were gypsies. I had thought they were a myth before talking to this guy at length. He was actually my calculus tutor before you call him a dumb racist (might have been the latter). My fiancee who works at a major theme park in florida has noted that gypses or “Roma” will frequently come in and use their children to help steal things and will make everyone’s lives miserable around them. Unpopular views and experiences…
This article is all about how the world treats Roma people. What about how the Roma interacts with the rest of the world? This article is very one-sided view. Roma people have been persecuted through out the ages but there are many cultural values held by this community that has also caused this problem. The Roma view the rest of the world differently from them – they have a rigid views that prevent their integration with the other western communities. Roma people themselves have to do more to ensure that the stereotypes associated with their communitiy is removed – they must not resort to theiving and believe in the value of hard work. You just have to see the documentaries across the youtube platform to understand why the stereotypes have stuck with the Roma.
It’s not a totally undeserved stigmata. They are not stigmatised because they like to travel and are lovely people, they are stigmatised because they often live a stereotype life and bring stereotype problems with them. When a group don’t live by the rules of the majority of citizen, no matter where they come from, they will get rejected. That’s not racist, that’s human behavior.
The racism with Roma people is not your usual case of racism. The hate towards them was not created without any reason, all that stigma exists because once it was probably very true and it remains partially true through out the time. There is a deep cultural distrust towards them. If you get in front of one of the classic example of Roma men in the streets or he bumps into you, chances are that you will be robbed. Paradoxically that distrust is what makes these cases more true, since they grow in a environment that believe that they are lets say all thiefs, majority of them are going to become one, but you also can’t just stop having that fear of them because then you are going to become a target as well. What im saying is this can only be resolved through time, a lot of generations needs to pass, centuries. If they want to be accepted, they will have to change their culture, lose their identity, become more similar to the natives. Multiculturalism doesnt work.
I travel quite a bit and it’s very unfortunate. The only Roma people I’ve met were either trying to rob me or scam me. I was forced to defend myself on two occasions. I caught a ten year old girl picking my pocket in Naples. I gave her all the cash I had on me, it made me So profoundly sad, I am in the corner of every downtrodden people, and I hate the racism, they face. And I’m in favor of what ever it takes to get any group out of poverty but you have to meet mainstream society half way.
There is no doubt that Gypsies have been oppressed in the past. But today, the problems are largely self-inflicted, perhaps not everywhere. They are a clan culture, and clan cultures always perform poorly in modern societies. They do not try to integrate, and actively isolate themselves. They are extremely racist and speak very badly of others, because they think no one understands what they are saying.\r It is far from all Gypsies who are the problem. But they have so many individuals (percentage) who misbehave that their bad reputation is not unjustified.\r There are other minorities who perform well, so the problem is not racism or outsiders.
First, the words Roma and Romani are not universally accepted by the “Roma” peoples across Europe. In Portugal they call themselves Ciganos and in Spain they are Gitanos. Both words mean Gypsy and they are very proud of it. Romani has a hint of Latinx, a word made up by white liberals and imposed on people whether or not they identify as such. This article does a great job of ignoring the complicated nuances of the relations between Romani and society at large. The article is all about how Romani are oppressed by Europeans, the implication being that Europeams are all racists. Truth is, some of the most racist things I ever heard came from the mouths of Gypsies. And they are not shy about expressing their prejudices to your face. At no point in the article do they mention the criminal culture of the Romani, the patriarchal sexism and violence, the self segregation and xenophobia of all other races. The article ignores all of that and expects you to ingore it too. It’s not journalism if you leave out the bits that don’t massage your narrative.
feels like I’m alone in the comments with that, but honestly most of the encounters I had with “gypsy’s” have been positive. they were very lively and friendly and funny people. only the living conditions weren’t the greatest, i think a little more structure in that could do allot in improving their reputation.
I went to school with some Romani and it wasn’t pleasant to say the least. Most of them didn’t really care about hygiene or education, but the biggest problem was their aggression towards us. The boys would constantly mock, tease and assault us whether it was verbally or physicaly. I have a younger sister and I’m concerned about hor going to school with such kids which is, I think, understandable. I don’t want to say that they are mostly bad people, there are regions where they are polite, clean and well educated, but those who aren’t should become somehow. The thing I also want to point out is that they have a bit more rights than the natives since they are considered a minority and most government bodies won’t even interact with them so they have the freedom to cause harm to society. I’m not a specialist nor a professional in the field of social engineering but I think that they should be socialized a bit and introduced to our coulture since I believe that there is a clash between their culture and ours. Don’t take the comment as hateful or negative, it’s just reality, but I’m always open for debate.
I am Romani/Roma. One historical thing people may find interesting is that centuries ago when Roma people and tribes started arriving in Europe the Europeans mistook them as Egyptians due to the physical apearance…thus coining the word Gypsy in all it’s forms…. depending on the language…Gitanos…Zingari…Cigani…Tzigani…Gitanes…etc. They were wrong then and are wrong now. Names of our many different tribes original names go back to India…Roma….Sinti…Domari…Lom…..Zargari just to name a few.
im a Mailman in Switzeland, one day i saw a White van with Irish plates parked up in my small town, its pretty unusual, then i noticed 3-4 Romas going all over the place door to door, they were trying to scam elderly people in the town to buy new roof guttering installations probably marked up 3-4 times what they are worth. Now having grown up in NZ my english is on par with theirs so i ask them where they’re from, the oldest one immediately got hostile, as ive clearly interupted them in their money making scheme. i called the cops which eventually had them move along, apparently they had already done so from several other towns. Theyre not hated because theyre Romas, theyre hated because they really do just bring trouble and petty crime with them wherever they go
A thousand years and still haven’t been able to assimilate normal society, that sounds more like a problem with their culture. If you never have the desire to better yourself through education and hard work, if you don’t teach your children to have respect for the laws, then you can expect “marginalized”. That holds true for any culture.
I am Romani and I will admit without issue that we have massive issues in our values and culture that leads towards crime and just being generally bad actors in society I do not know why, but my family was very, very far removed from the old value system and it’s for the better. We should preserve the good parts of our culture and realie that we need to be decent members of society if we want to be accepted
Has a kid I saw gypsies come in a supermarket as an elderly lady fell by the condiments aisle and as everyone trying to help her four Younger boys ran out of the store with armfuls of steaks I was impressed of the military precision of there action . By the way after the boys was clear of the Area the Old lady had a miraculous recovery and just walked out the store Manager didn’t realize he was robbed until later on
I found this to be an interesting place for me to start researching the Romani people. I’m from the US and the only insight I get has been from tv and movies (which isn’t the best). I know just about nothing that isn’t a stereotype I’ve heard. In school we are taught about the Jewish holocaust but we never really hear of the other groups of people who were killed during the holocaust as well. Thank you for enlightening me and helping me along my journey of learning more about the people and culture.
It’s even more sad tho that the majority of romani people have adapted themselves to these stereotypes. I’m from central europe and the gypsy communities outside of major cities are just the most violent groups I’ve ever seen. We do fear them, they are arrogant, and do bully others. On another hand, majority doesn’t include everyone. I’ve had a romani classmate. Nice guy, we even were friends throughout the majority of my school years. He was quite smart too and studied well, against all the stereotypes. He wanted to persuade higher form of education. But his family pulled him back to them. He never studied afterwards and now i see on his instagram acc that all he’s doing is drinking and perusal football… I genuinely feel sad for him
My culture as a part-roma white-looking girl has been sort of taken from me by my great grandfather. He abused my italian/Roma great grandmother and grandmother out of her culture in suburban America and I had no idea my people had to go through this because of minority erasure. I want to know more of my culture Roma-wise and not just the Italian, German, and Ashkenazi parts. I sympathize with the discriminated Roma who aren’t as white looking as me or not as Americanized as me.
My grandfather came to the US in 1929. He is (as far as I am aware) the ONLY family member to survive the Holocaust. His brothers lost their businesses and were taken to the camps. His Ellis Island papers to not say Roma in any form, says Serbia. My mother told me that he told her that we were Roma, but that he really didn’t like to talk about any of it. It is really sad to know that your ancestors were wiped from the planet.
It’s sad but I have had two experiences with Roma and they were really negative so it’s hard for me to get over it. I also don’t know any other Roma so in my mentality it’s hard to see it as isolated incidents. I always have know that they were stereotyped and unfortunately the experiences I had only reenforced those stereotypes. The history of oppression does explain some concerns to an extent and the circle of poverty but in some ways still doesn’t justify if a group continues to use that as an excuse for how they treat other people.
I had a small apartement in the II. district (affluent neighborhood) in Budapest. My tenant decided to buy their own home so he left my apartment. I was looking for a new tenant for this little nothing fancy but very much livable apartment. Skip forward two weeks a Roma woman and her little boy came to view my apartment and they liked it and wanted to rent it out. I was a little apprehensive but they had the money upfront for a months rent and a 2 month security deposit so I agrreed to rent it out. In the first couple of weeks nothing happened but at the end of the month I got a call from her telling me she wouldn’t be able to pay at the end of the month but every three months. That’s not what we agreed but it’s a single mom I was like sure. Skip forward 6 months after a shit load of complaints from neighbours, a Roma man moving in, Noise complaints and let’s not forget not paying me a single dime after I rented out the place they left. The apartment was incredibly dirty I had to get rid of the bed,sofa, tv was stolen, kitchen damaged. I had to get new locks and I never heard anything back from them since.\r \r Take this as you will I was trying to be the better man and I got screwed over. I’m not saying all roma are bad but the stereotype didn’t fall out of the sky.
I remember as a kid their was a huge field near our house and it was full of Romani families and a lot of people hated them but a lot including my family liked them the men repaired things and the women did beautiful knitting they knitted my cousins christening shawl and also me and my sister played with the kids and if my parents wanted to go out they Romani babysat us and were so nice one time my parents went to a wedding that was for adults and people over the age of 16 only and my parents would be gone for the weekend so we stayed with the Romani and their trailers were beautiful when they were eventually moved on I cried for ages and I remember hugging the kids who were my friends and some of the female adults and sobbing please don’t go and they said we have no choise we’re so sorry but I found them lovely warm people and I didn’t notice that they had darker skin than me and my Sister as she’s blonde and I’m redhead and we’re very fair and also I remember a young female maybe in her teens and I used to say your so pretty you remind me of Esmeralda and I showed her my Esmeralda Barbie she laughed saying why thank you think I gave her the doll to keep
My first time coming across the Roma was when I was in Berlin and they kept trying to scam me and my boyfriend. Then they snuck into the Berlin Wall museum and tried to trick people there. The museum guy came running upstairs with a broom and then all the Roma started to climb out the windows or hid in the museum until they could escape the guy. I was laughing because I’m from the country side in Bavaria and it was just new to me.
Wait wait wait, I’m all for everything that this article says, but I do see an important oversight here. Everything is “people should treat Roma perfectly, like they are family”, “Countries should give Roma respect”, “Organizations should cater to Roma needs” etc. And that is great and I’m all for it, but I don’t see anywhere about Roma people doing a self examination, why do some groups of roma people behave in very inappropiate ways. The thing is the article makes it seem like there is absolutely no reason for people having a poor view on Roma people, but if there was no reason well there probably wouldn’t be a poor view right? Get what I’m saying? I think if we are to advance socially everybody should take responsability, not just outside groups. When you approach a person that is having personal problems (be it depression, drugs or whatever) you don’t tell him “oh don’t worry you sit back and change nothing, do no self examination, I’ll change everyone around you first”. And of course I’m not talking about changing their culture, I’m talking about changing things that affect others negatively.
I don’t care what anybody say. I’ve met many romani that travel to America and every time I have been scammed or attempted to be scammed by one. The last time it happened I confronted the individual and actually paid him to tell me his family history and what they are doing in America. He told me that he was with over 50 family members that travel all around the US throughout the year scamming and then take their loop back to their home country and they have no intention of integrating or changing their ways and it’s a part of their culture. He left me with a strong message to not ever trust a gypsy.
I’m a Rudar on my mother’s side from România, which is supposedly a subset of the Roma people, although the exact origins of the Rudars(or in English Boyash) aren’t entirely clear. Despite supposedly being related to the gypsies, we don’t speak romani, we don’t play the same kind of music, and we don’t commit crimes. Instead, we mostly work, we do carpentry and masonry. My grandfather used to do carpentry on the side when he wasn’t working on the railroads. Outside of some of the dress, there is almost nothing in common between us and the gypsies, in fact the latter mostly hate us, yet we’re still called romani. The idea that there’s no such thing as a gypsy lifestyle, that being a gypsy is an ethnicity identical to being a roma, is a lie. There is no one, single romani culture, every single tribe is different. The Romanian roma are different from the Hungarian roma, who both have almost nothing in common with the Spanish and Welsh roma. There is no sense of fraternity or solidarity between “us,” if you go to România you’ll see big palaces built by gypsies who’ve made their money primarily off of drug and human trafficking(50% of victims from Eastern Europe, I believe are gypsy girls) right next door to a family of gypsies who live with about the same standard of living as people did in the 18th century, and live off of begging and petty thievery. The idea that integrating more gypsies is a destructive and racist process, or that somehow a huge amount of culture will be lost, is absurd.