The rights expert emphasized the need for legislation and community programs to help detect, provide advice, rehabilitation, education, and shelter for enslaved individuals. Over-the-top brides were the main draw in Channel 4’s series on Traveller communities, but when Julie Bindel visited, she found prejudice, poor health, and poverty. Gail Johnson, a wedding planner in Tucker, Ga., echoed the sentiment, stating that there is an unspoken type of code that Black people don’t do.
Americans have long viewed marriage between a white man and a white woman as a sacred union, but marriages between African Americans have seldom been. In India, bride trafficking is fuelled by skewed sex ratios, with bride-price often portrayed as a sign of slavery. Marriage was also widely regarded as a safeguard against the allegedly enslaved.
Eligible returnees can apply to receive reintegration. Returning to their home country from abroad can involve reestablishing closer connections with those left behind and making new friends. Slaves have historically been forced to marry their master or their masters’ kin, other slaves, or other persons, resulting in a variety of issues.
Slaves have historically been forced to marry their master or their masters’ kin, other slaves, or other persons, resulting in a variety of issues. Sahibas’ future remains uncertain, as she cannot go home to her family after her marriage ends. Enslaved women and men could be removed from their marriage by sale, kidnapping, dowries, inheritance, or property.
📹 Married to Islamic State: The women Australia doesn’t want | Four Corners
In this exclusive Four Corners investigation, the former brides of Islamic State reveal the extraordinary details of their lives in the IS …
How were female slaves punished?
Whipping, a common form of slave punishment, demanded the removal of clothing. For the female slave, this generally meant disrobing down to the waist. Although her state of half dress allowed the woman some modesty, it also exposed her naked breasts to all eyes.
Were slaves allowed to have children?
Motherhood was central to the great majority of enslaved womens lives. While some women attempted not to become mothers, and a minority were unable to reproduce, most women negotiated childbirth and raising children within the confines of the slave regime, and they took a lot of care in raising their daughters to survive enslavement as females. Despite the fact that bonded women knew their children would be born into enslavement, most became mothers and many found parenthood a source of joy and comfort, as many WPA interviews with formerly enslaved women in the 1930s convey. Likewise, Harriet Jacobs described in her autobiography that her mothers love made her determined to secure a better future for her children by escaping bondage (Harriet Jacobs, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl (New York: Dover, 2001 1861), 130). Women put their children first and strove to protect them and motherhood gave women the opportunity to express maternal love, to receive the love of a child, to gain a sense of worth, to give and receive comfort, and to nurture; notwithstanding all the agonies of sale, separation, ill-health, physical punishments and death that enslavement brought. Enslaved women tended to give birth to their first child at a relatively young age and have short intervals between births, in part due to a lack of contraception, but also because of the pressures placed upon women by slaveholders who were ever-anxious to keep their slave population increasing without the purchase of new people. Frequent childbirth and over-work had a detrimental impact on enslaved womens health, as well as maternal and infant mortality.
Most women received just one month off work when postpartum, and they were also regularly required to continue daily field or house labor until very close to giving birth itself. The physical and emotional stress of childbearing under slavery necessitated many women to also cope with the death of their infants. So common were infant deaths in the Lowcountry that the Gullah language produce two words to describe a firstborn child: fus one (first one) and Comesee (first born child that lived). At the same time, slaveholder in the Lowcountry did regularly lower the daily required task labor of pregnant women as they realized that lower morality rates among women and children led to greater profits for them. This did not completely offset, though, how susceptible pregnant women and their young children were to environmental and medical factors that led to death on Antebellum plantations. White doctors only rarely attended the births of enslaved women, but enslaved midwives, known as grannies and white slaveholding women often assisted confined women. White slaveholding women were involved to whatever degree they decided upon, without regard for enslaved womens desire as to who they wanted to help assist them in birth. Many women gave birth to mixed-race or what used to be called mulatto children following sexual assaults at the hands of white men, and while white women sometimes regarded these children with hostility, they were both loved and accepted within enslaved communities themselves.
Women remained at the heart of mother-centered (or matrifocal) enslaved families. They strove to raise their children as well as they could, for example by advising their daughters on the perils of enslavement for women who faced physical violence by slaveholders of various kinds, ill-health, and sale and separation. Slaveowners more commonly sold men alone, and mothers and infants together, although they often separated older children from their parents. They also abused enslaved mothers ability to lactate by forcing them to wetnurse white infants, or those of other enslaved women who were needed to labor elsewhere.
What did slaves eat?
The standard rations enslaved people received were cornmeal and salted fish, which they harvested themselves.
These monotonous rations provided protein and carbohydrates but lacked essential nutrients and were not always sufficient for the demands of daily work. Enslaved people created variety in their diets by keeping gardens, raising poultry, foraging for plants, fishing, and trapping and hunting wild animals.
…one peck, one gallon of maize per week; this makes one quart a day, and half as much for the children, with 20 herrings each per month.
– Julian Ursyn Niemcewicz, Mount Vernon visitor, 1798. Washington believed that he provided his workforce an adequate amount of food (“as much as they can eat without waste and no more”). Enslaved people did not always agree. On one occasion in 1793, enslaved overseer Davy Gray informed Washington that the people on his farm “would often be without a mouthful for a day, and sometimes two days.” Sensitive to criticism that he did not feed his slaves enough, Washington agreed to increase the rations slightly.
What did female slaves do in the house?
Southern coloniesedit. Regardless of location, slaves endured hard and demeaning lives, but labor in the southern colonies was most severe. The southern colonies were slave societies; they were socially, economically, and politically dependent on slave labor, had a large enslaved population, and allowed masters extensive power over their slaves unchecked by the law.8 Plantations were the economic power structure of the South, and male and female slave labor was its foundation. Early on, slaves in the South worked primarily in agriculture, on farms and plantations growing indigo, rice, and tobacco; cotton became a major crop after the 1790s. Female slaves worked in a wide variety of capacities. They were expected to do field work as well as have children, and in this way increase the slave population. In the years before the American Revolution, the female slave population grew mainly as a result of natural increase and not importation. Once slaveholders realized that the reproductive function of the female slave could yield a profit, the manipulation of procreative sexual relations became an integral part of the sexual exploitation of female slaves.12 Many slave women raised their children without much assistance from males. Enslaved women were counted on not only to do their house and fieldwork, but also to bear, nourish, and rear the children whom slaveholders sought to continually replenish their labor force. As house slaves, women were domestic servants: cooking, sewing, acting as maids, and rearing the planters children. Later on, they were used in many factories where they were kept at lower maintenance costs.citation needed.
Revolutionary eraedit. During the Revolutionary War (1775–1783) enslaved women served on both sides, the Loyalist army as well as the Patriots, as nurses, laundresses, and cooks. But as historian Carol Berkin writes, African American loyalties were to their own future, not to Congress or to the king.13 Enslaved women could be found in army camps and as camp followers. They worked building roads, constructing fortifications, and laundering uniforms, but they remained slaves rather than refugees. Masters usually hired these women out to the military, sometimes hiring out their children as well.14 Enslaved women could also be found working in the shops, homes, fields, and plantations of every American colony. It is estimated that by 1770, there were more than 47,000 enslaved blacks in the northern colonies, almost 20,000 of them in New York. More than 320,000 slaves worked in the Chesapeake colonies, making 37 percent of the population of the region African or African American. Over 187,000 of these slaves were in Virginia. In the Lower South, there were more than 92,000 slaves. South Carolina alone had over 75,000 slaves, and by 1770 planters there were importing 4,000 Africans a year. In many counties in the Lower South, the slave population outnumbered the white.15.
Although service in the military did not guarantee enslaved people their freedom, black men had the opportunity to escape slavery by enlisting in the army. During the disruption of war, both men and women ran away. Men were more likely to escape, as pregnant women, mothers, and women who nursed their elderly parents or friends seldom abandoned those who depended on them.16 So many slaves deserted their plantations in South Carolina, that there were not enough field hands to plant or harvest crops. As food grew scarce, the blacks who remained behind suffered from starvation or enemy attack. The Crown issued certificates of manumission to more than 914 women as a reward for serving with Loyalist forces.17 But many women who had won their freedom lost it again through violence and trickery and the venality of men entrusted with their care.18 Others who managed to secure their freedom faced racial prejudice, discrimination, and poverty. When loyalist plantations were captured, enslaved women were often taken and sold for the soldiers profit.14 The Crown did keep promising manumission slaves, evacuating them along with troops in the closing days of the war, and resettling more than 3,000 Black Loyalists in Nova Scotia, and others in the Caribbean, and England. In 1792 it established Freetown, in what is now Sierra Leone, as a colony for Poor Blacks from London, as well as Black Loyalists from Canada who wanted to relocate.
Were slaves allowed to drink?
Alcohol and Slavery These codes governed all aspects of slave life, prohibiting living by oneself, traveling without a pass, gathering in groups, and owning a weapon. Buying or drinking alcohol was prohibited except under conditions defined by the slaves owner (Larkins, 1965).
Did slave owners ever marry their slaves?
During the period of legal slavery, marriage and slavery were closely interconnected and sometimes overlapped. Slave owners could force their slaves to marry, remain unmarried, or separate from their spouses. They could also marry them.
The forms of power that allowed slaveholders to coerce enslaved persons into unwanted marriages (or out of wanted ones) havent disappeared.
First, slavery has not ended. African women and children are caught in illegal networks controlled by sex traffickers who cater for a persistent demand in vulnerable (and therefore sexually abusable) persons. This, today, is outlawed and prosecutable as either slavery or forced marriage. But in the past such a demand was largely met through the provision of enslaved persons who could be used for sexual and conjugal purposes.
Why were slaves not allowed to marry?
At Mount Vernon, the numbers of enslaved males and females in the summer of 1799 were fairly equal. A series of lists made by George Washington in the summer before his death indicates that roughly two-thirds of the plantations enslaved adults were married.1 These marriages were acknowledged by both the enslaved community and the Washingtons. However, they were not recognized or protected by the legal system, because enslaved people were considered property and not persons in the eyes of the law.
For those enslaved at Mount Vernon, marriage represented the opportunity to exercise choice in a life that afforded little, if any, personal control over basic life issues including occupation, housing, clothing, and freedom of movement. However, even this decision had limitations. When one member of a couple lived at a plantation other than Mount Vernon, the pair planning to marry first needed permission from George Washington, as long-distance marriages necessitated a certain amount of traveling back and forth between the two plantations. Getting the permission of a master would have been in keeping with a 1785 Virginia law that stated that enslaved people could not travel away from home without a pass or letter of authorization from a master, employer, or overseer.2.
The distance was a significant stress factor in marriages. Of the 96 married enslaved people working on Washingtons five farms in 1799, only 36 lived in the same household as their spouse and children. Another 38 had spouses living on one of Washingtons other farms, dictated by work assignments.
Why were slaves allowed to marry?
9 Slaves were prohibited from marrying because, as long as they were in a state of bondage, they lacked the capacity to enter into any legally enforceable civil contracts. Once emancipated and granted the capacity to contract, the right of freed slaves to marry was undisputed.
What did slaves do with babies?
When a planters child was born or married, he or she might receive the gift of a black attendant. Mothers were taken from their own children to nurse the offspring of their masters. And slave children were torn from mothers and brought into the house to be raised alongside the masters sons and daughters.
How many hours of sleep did slaves get?
Day after day, the Africans cultivated crops, tended to animals, and served their owners in any way possible. Sixteen to eighteen hours of work was the norm on most West Indian plantations, and during the season of sugarcane harvest, most slaves only got four hours of sleep.
Before the establishment of Christianity in the West Indies, slaves looked to their own system of belief, brought from their individual African tribal communities. The African religions were religions of spirit, not of doctrine. At the same time, most African religions believed in the existence of one supreme god. This belief, shared with Christianity, made it easier for Africans to understand the Christian religion. African religious beliefs held that spirits of ancestors and natural phenomena immediately affected people’s lives. Their religion saw man himself as, essentially, a spirit. Death rites were important to ascertain that the spirit of the departed remained benign rather than hostile to those left behind. However, African religions did not offer an idea of heaven, and this too attracted many slaves towards Christianity. For many, heaven promised a reward for suffering in the physical world.
While some West Indian slaves opposed European Christianity, many more would eventually come to adopt and adapt at least some of its elements. Missionaries from the Moravians, the Baptists, and the Methodists all engaged in the process of Christianization in the West Indies. By the middle of the eighteenth century, Moravian chapels and mission houses were in populated areas of many of the British-controlled islands. Missionaries argued to planters that slaves needed religion and that planters too would benefit from the conversion.
However, many planters felt that the conversion of their slaves would jeopardize their own position of power. Richard Ligon’s firsthand account of planter life in the West Indies reveals evidence of this feeling as early as the mid-eighteenth century. His account, A True and Exact History of the island of Barbados, contains a passage where Ligon is speaking to a planter about his wishes to convert one of the planters slaves (Sambo) to Christianity.
Did slaves fall in love with their masters?
Unless it was a forced rape or unwilling sex regularly perpetrated by an evil master, much like the case of Robert Newsom and Celia in 1855, it was quite possible for an enslaved woman to have a sexual relationship based on mutual consent with her master.
Did slaves have multiple wives?
While polygamous (or plural) marriage had declined by antebellum times, on a few large Lowcountry plantations the practice of men having multiple wives continued. It was much more common for enslaved women to partake in serial marriage after slaveholders sold their husbands away or when widowed.
Young enslaved people enjoyed the rituals and festivities of Saturday night dances (also known as frolics) where they sang, danced and courted members of their communities. Likewise, these women and men enjoyed the celebrations associated with those entering wedlock. These often involved a religious service in which couples sometimes symbolically jumped over a broom before partaking in a religious ceremony, enjoying food, and dancing thereafter. Recent scholarship explains that jumping the broom, an Anglo-adopted ritual used by some enslaved African Americans, played the important role of validating their marriages in a society where legal marriage was impossible. There is also evidence that it signified entrance into a new life and sweeping away the old. Well aware that enslaved marriage provided an easy route to valuable future offspring, slaveholders regularly sponsored activities related to courtship and marriage on their plantations, or else enabled their slaves to travel to neighboring plantations for social gatherings by granting them written passes:
De slaves worked hard in de fiel’s but unless de work wus pushin’ dey had sadday evenin’ off ter go a-fishin an do anything de wanted ter do. Two or three times a year Marse James let dem have a dance an’ invite all in de neighborhood slaves. Dey had corn shuckin’s ever’ fall an’ de other slaves cud come ter dem. De candy pullin’s wus a big affair…Dey’s come from all over de neighborhood ter cook de lasses molasses an’ pull de candy. While de candy cooled dey’d play drappin’ de handkerchief an’ a heap of other games. De courtin’ couples liked dese games ‘case dey could set out or plan an’ court all dey pleased. Dey often make up dere min’s ter ax de marster iffen dey could marry, too, at dese parties.
Anna Wright, interview with Federal Writers Project, North Carolina, circa 1937.
I’m a Muslim but I’m not stupid they knew what they where getting themselves into. Not one of them mentioned the torture the poor Yazidi girls suffered at the hands of there husbands, how they where gang raped how they where held as slaves how they where murdered, how so many innocent people died not one of them mentioned it. Had the IS been successful they would not of been in this documentary. Yes I feel sorry for the kids but my heart breaks for those children that where made orphans due to their husbands and sons. Even hell doesn’t have a place for IS.
Red flags: – saying Islamic State instead of ISIS – smiling while telling her story like it’s a romatic fairytale – going in to details while describing how she wanted her husband to look like and where he should come from. She seemed very willingly to get married – expressing how much she wanted to get pregnant while living in a warzone – life was “good” at the beginning while living under ISIS. Because they were strong at first of course. – they fled to Al Hol from Baghouz. Baghouz is the last place where ISIS fled to to fight until the very end. Only the diehard supporters went with them. Furthermore, Nisrine annoyed the hell out of me with her “better-than-thou” complex.
I don’t like how that father Kamal says these women are “victims” because they had so many kids, or married several ISIS fighters. The actual victims are the Yazidi women. Why are there so few documentaries about them? Why do so many in the west seem so much more sympathetic towards women that willingly joined ISIS than to Yazidis that survived slavery and genocide?
“I had nowhere to hide” Good well now you know how your victims felt. She said “I did nothing wrong” The lack of understanding of what you did is why you are a threat. You just proved why you should not ever be allowed back! The govt might decide to let them back in but i can assure you most Australians won’t welcome them back nor should they.
I can’t feel sorry for these women . The way that Nesrin was telling her story smiling gave me the chills . Who goes “helping” giving aid to people,doesn’t even bring a bag but brings her passport. The only time she cried is when she told how she was separated from her husband and left alone. I have never ever seen someone telling their traumatic story giggling and laughing. Poor babies though they deserve better.
All I hear is “my husband died, now I’m upset.” There is no other sorrow except the loss of their husband. No sympathy for the war they joined nor feeling bad about their Choices. No sorrow the loss of other lives. I bet if their husbands where still alive and well they’d be content and not want to leave. These women need to stop playing the victim card.
When she went there-she was about 22. In 2018 I was 21. Two girls were slaughtered in Marocco and a article of the act was posted on the internet. I read and article about their deaths and, since I did not believe that such thing could be done and no one could do anything to punish the violent act-I decided to check if I could find that article. I wish I never did. Just thinking about it- I can hear the women screaming in agony. NO HUMAN would do such thing to another! Those people are NO HUMAN! They teach their kids how to hate and for such thing-there is no redemption!
As interesting as these docu’s are, there’s a lot of them. Giving women who WILLINGLY joined a platform. Yet there’s thousands of Yazidi girls and women forced into that life and there’s barely any converge on them. I’d much prefer to hear their stories of survival and these girls’. Now their young kids are a different story, they had NO say in this and I’d gladly welcome them back to my country.
A family member says: Bring them back to Australia, set up confinement for them here, then deal with the legalities here. That’s a brilliant idea….NOT!!! Why should this be dealt with on Australian soil? Who the hell do you think will have to pay for this? Harding working every day Aussie tax payers! NO THANK YOU!!! I pay my way to live in this amazing country I call home. They left Australia to live this life, not our problem. They made their bed, they can now lie in. Nesrine……way too happy for my liking and the most painful interview I’ve ever watched. All smiles, life there can’t be that bad for her.
I feel very sorry for their parents. These women were all grown adults who made very bad choices. They’ve not only ruined their own lives, they’ve ruined their families lives. Actions have consequences. I migrated to Australia and it’s been brilliant to me and my family, I’d never fight against the country that has given me a safe and secure life.
I’m having a hard time feeling sorry for any of these women. You followed these men around like little dogs depending on them completely whilst bringing children into a war……. I don’t believe that every single one of these women were tricked. And they have the nerve to ask what they have done wrong and wonder why they are considered a threat.
Being a father to a 2 yr old daughter my heart broke for the little girl in maroon. I wanted to hug her and tell her it’s gonna be okay. But I would be lying to her. She unfortunately being used as propaganda by her own mother, these women pretty well knew their choices. I would request Aussies don’t take them back, except take children and rehabilitate them.
This is gross honestly you choose the life you live, you want to romanticize terrorism then you get what you deserve… and on the other hand … we have women here that NEED help and resources and they didn’t make a choice to leave … I am disgusted .. those women deserve what they get and for their children that too is on them …
Very difficult situation …these ladies choosen to be part to the Islamic state and married men who are fighters now they want to come back to the safe and democratic state their Islamic state was fighting and describing as a Hell …now they want their rights recognized ..sorry for the kids but I can really understand the Australian government in not willing to host orthodox Islamist because there is no integration possible in a western culture and avoid social and cultural problems amoung the Australian state ….more and less this is
With so many extended family members all going to the region, I dont believe any of them were unaware. Some of them sold property and made decisions to indicate they were not coming back. Nobody sells their house to go on a 2 week holiday to Lebanon. I would not bring them back to Australia. They would be better suited living in an Islamic country. Many of them have a connection to Lebanon, so the Australian government should do a deal with Lebanon to take them, or any other Islamic country in the Middle East I also dont believe these women just did housework. Reports from women who were taken as sex slaves said ISIS women were involved in brutalizing them, and these women were married to senior leaders of ISIS, they most likely had leadership roles. I dont trust any of them. Once you have lost your humanity to brutalize other human beings because of religious brainwashing, theres no hope for them. Its really sad that in 2019 there are still people brainwashed by religious fairytales, and are willing to throw their lives away over a fake religion.
It is a tragic story. When the women met with their parents, it was genuinely heartbreaking as they knew it was only for a short moment. I felt for the parents, but they will never be objective in this situation because they are their kids and have unconditional love for them. It is hard for me to believe that their husbands tricked these women and were completely unaware. Any followers of radical movements are dangerous to society. Adults should face the consequences of their actions, but these children are innocent and are victims of their parent’s behaviours. The Australian government could consider helping relocate the children to their Australian families; however, it is tricky as we do not know if the children have the right to get citizenship due to their parents’ actions. Also, giving their children away would deprive them of hope and a sense of living…what a deadlock. .
These women are holding their children hostage, most of the kids could come back, just listen to the lady at the beginning this makes no sense my son can go back with no problem, but I can’t, but he gets his passport through me. I’m serious, just really listen to her tone she almost despises her child bc she feels why him and not me, I’m more important, without me he’s nothing. if these women cared for their kids they send them back, but they’re using the kids to get back into the country. i hate how these reporters put the little girl on camera to make you feel bad, but maybe the reporters should tell her why she can’t come home or ask your mother to explain it on camera so we could all hear. guaranteed her mom bad mouths Australia to her blames everyone except herself.
To all those saying theyy had no chance and wanted to escape earlier: They stayed with ISIS til the very last moment, til the very last city fell… that doesnt scream insubordination to me. Much more it feels like they foolishly believed in their self constructed fantasy world until the very end. No one can be sure whether they are lying to get out or not. But make no mistake: a few months ago they were without a doubt singing a very different tune and it wasn’t a nice one.
This article is so heartbreaking on all sides, I think it’s safe to say for the parties involved you have to think through before taking actions. Parents should guide their Children in Love please. There are some things we do in Africa where we get to know the families of whom our children want to get married, it’s like you are doing an investigative research. To avoid problems, you don’t even travel out of the state without at least a person or more people knowing, sometimes it feels like people are all up in our business but that’s just how it is. I cannot travel without a family member knowing, I don’t travel without precision or a plan about where I am going to.
It’s strange to me how badly these women wanna go home And make it look like it’s “for their babies”… Then why didn’t any of them ask for their babies to at least be saved, if they could not be? If I knew my home state would never take me back I would at least ask for my family to take my baby and save them. They’re liars
I’ve seen documentarys about abused Muslim women who’ve been stolen/ raped/ forced into marriage and the one thing I’ve always noticed is that they are usually TERRIFIED to show their faces so willingly on cameras because first of all they’re traumatized while being scared to death and they’re deeply ashamed. Many of them can’t even go back to their families because they “lossed their honor” by being kidnapped and THEY are the ones who are blamed, these woman are not only showing their faces but laughing and smiling about it all ! Such strange and unusual behavior for victims of these types of crimes . 🤨
I’m sorry i just woke up at caught the last few minutes of this and i can tell you that i see none of these women blame themselves for the situation they’re in, they had to know something was up when their husbands wanted to pack them up and move them here, ppl don’t just want to go back to this homeland for nothing, it’s always bc they’ve been radicalized. you’re telling me they never saw any signs of their husband’s behavior changing? i have a question how so many women were married to the same man? bc if I’m calculating right, it means they were married b4 getting here and that tells me you weren’t even following the laws in the country you called home.(Aussie) unless I’m wrong, and you can have that many wives there. When your husbands were alive you women didn’t care if they killed your own families now you expect the rest of us just to welcome you in with open arms. I’m in America and i wouldn’t want any of you who are old enough to know better, bc if you’re old enough to know better and still went then you’re old enough to be lying and will just pick up with another man in the Islamic state who is married to these terrorist ideas. my guess is if you really y want what’s best for yourself and kids give up the kids and let them leave there without you, but i don’t want any of you in America,and as far as i can see neither does Australia or anyone else. p/s i kinda feel b4 the camera came back over, the little girl is told to grab on and not let go to play on heartstrings.
Yeah, totally believable story. We were on holiday, I went to help refugees & didn’t know I had went in to a completely different country. Like she didn’t already know her cousin was there and that he’d convinced other family members to go over and fight, it’s a complete coincidence. Man don’t you hate it when you go on holiday and that happens 🙄. Well seeing the other woman’s husband and bother in law were running ahead of her from the bullets n just left her behind.
If these formerly Australian women are not actual radical Islam converts why can’t they get jobs in Syria? Ban together, have a few women look after all the children, and the others go work to support the group? That’s what widows all over the world do when their husbands die. I do not believe the first woman (Australian-Lebanese) who said she ran away from a vacation in Lebanon with her family to “do volunteer work at the Turkey/Syrian border.” Hogwash. She met an ISIS recruiter online and agreed to go to Syria to find a husband to take care of her. That is exactly how it works check out the true movie Profile. The women get themselves to Turkey and they’re taken across the border. I’d have grave concerns if the country I lived in repatriated the wives of dead ISIS fighters.
They ‘snuck away’ to deliver aid? Yeah. I dont feel hatred for these women, I feel absolutely nothing. To those who do feel empathy, hold onto that. You will need if even only one of these women was to return to Australia and bring harm to someone you love. That anyone would risk their own children’s lives in such a way says a lot about who they are, brainwashed or otherwise.
little 9 year old Maysa Assad broke my heart. I know that she did not choose to go there. To live in harsh conditions and in a tent. The children are victims of selfish parents. I think that they (the children) should be allowed to return alone. Given most are still very young, they will be able to readjust to normal life and their community/ grandparents should look after them. The women on the other hand is another story and each case should be investigated fully and thoroughly before making any decision. All in all, let this be a lesson to people thinking of going to that part of the world. Be vigilant and don’t get duped. If you want to do aide work – go through legitimate registered charity organisations and websites.
I do feel compassion for these people .. I think about the question that the mother asked: why are we a danger to Australia? .. and this question came out inside of me .. Why are Muslims so easy to radicalised? This phenomena is global among muslims from australia, China, India, Russian, Africa, Malaysia, Indonesia, Europe, America .. and the connecting tissue seems to the be the ideology of Islam ..
I’m an arab, i was born overseas… I’ve been calling australia home for the last 14 years….. tell ya what Zero sympathy from me mate…. woman, man, child, old, young YOU DONE THIS TO YOURSELF… you wanted to be part of the isis now you are… I would be really disappointed if the australian government let them back in…..
I don’t feel sorry for these women, but I am heartbroken for the little children. They didn’t make this choice. But I guess this is life; we all carry the burden and benefits of the choices our parents made when we were younger. The biggest question I have is why would someone want to leave a peaceful country (let alone Australia / UK ) and ‘choose’ to enter a territory where one knows there is war ongoing and anything bad can happen, when infact their parents made the choice to leave some of those countries and relocate to Australia.
Don’t bring your children to the west if you don’t want them to adapt to Western values, the problem is the parents who lives in the west yet don’t want their children to live a western lifestyle,why don’t you move to Pakistani, Afghanistan, Indonesia, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Iran or Sudan if your belief is so important to you??
You chose your paths for your children and for yourselves. I don’t feel sorry for you. At all. How can you sit there, tell these people you were forced to stay here and marry a terrorist before you go home to Australia. Really?? With a smile on your face, you are telling us this? Also…if it’s that bad there and they want out, they could send their kids back with these beautiful family members doing interviews. A good mother would grapple at any chance to get their kids out. I’ve seen this exact case thousands of times. Horrible mothers, horrible women.
This is a genuine question so please don’t attack me while responding. I see that many of you are laughing at and mocking the mothers saying that they’re making a lot of excuses and that it’s basically BS but couldn’t there be a percentage where the man could’ve been deceptive and they weren’t aware until it was too late? I’m aware that the majority of the time the women know what they’re getting themselves into and I agree but shouldn’t we have compassion on those who genuinely weren’t aware? I’m reminded of the movie in the 90s “Not Without My Daughter” which is based on a true story about how the mother was deceived by her Muslim husband. Could there not be instances where this is also the case? Just wondering 🤔
The first young woman: The giggling and laughing makes it difficult to believe she understands how devastating all this was for her family. It’s like she’s still playing a flirtatious game with the interviewer, the camera. Her whole world still revolves around her, or so it appears. Perhaps if young women took were encouraged to take themselves more seriously from the beginning, they would not be such easy prey. The second woman is able to tell her story without all the affectation, which makes it easier to relate to, to understand and empathize. I was forced into a marriage at an early age and though I remain a light spirit, I have no smiles and giggles when I attempt to explain the horror of the situation that is made worse because it is justified, indeed sanctified by religion. In my case it was Christianity; these women were victimized by Islam.
I’d like to ask the family members in Australia the following and that’s how I’d determine which women and children I’d help take out of Syria, if I were Superman or Rambo or Thor or someone with the power to free them: 1) Should your daughters serve time when they return home? 2) Were your daughters rebelling the Western Freedom & opted for ISIS way of life? 3) Did your daughters know they were going to become ISIS themselves? 4) Do your daughters deserve the current suffering in Syria? 5) Do you know any ISIS living in your midst? 6) Did or will any of your sons serve in the Australian military?
When you were a child and you get into deep shit like get caught with a mate smoking and dodging school. You then tell the cops/parents “no I never wanted to get involved or do any of this and I am innocent.” And you get that “I don’t believe you” look on their face…. that’s the same reaction most people feel about these woman.
These women do not even acknowledge the horrible things they stand for, the monsters they married and the real victims of ISIS. It seems like it is all about how they are suffering now, but no compassion for those they made suffer directly or indirectly. If they had a heart and a conscience, they would accept their current lives as punishment and only seek for help for their children.
So many holes in Nesrine’s ‘quite a story’ a bus could be driven through it. (Body language says she is not being completely honest.) And when she says “… in the beginning it was really good, there was normal, normal life. You get to know this new guy and then you slowly fall in love and your life just goes on…” undermines her whole diatribe. Zahara’s complaint of “You can just see how we are living; I mean we are living in a tent. Tent is home” – Not an extraordinary story at all. Even if not the life they envisioned, they look well fed, they have shelter and Mariam even appears to be wearing a little makeup? And then for Shayma to so naively say “I just wanna know why we are a danger for Australia? Why? What have we done to be a danger to Australia?” Marium does not understand the meaning of being broken. All about me, me, I, I, I, … barely mentioning the children and their plight, (Only Shayma does) which are the true victims here. My heart goes out to the children but these women made their choices, the children had no choice. Rescue the children, even repatriate them to their Australian families by all means but the mothers deserve to stay where they are, after all, they made the choice and seem to have been enjoying their lives right up until things went pear-shaped for Islamic State.
1..Did they know that doing what they did was an act of terror ? 2..Did they know that fighting or collaborating with a foreign power at war with Australia would prejudice their citizenship ; 3 Did they knowingly partake of the functions of that enemy namely ISIS ? YES, therefore they should stay where they are ….Its a case of they knew the law they knew what they were getting into willingly ..
I am struggling because whilst I can empathise with some of the suggestions they were duped by husband’s I am more concerned that the children really are rarely mentioned other than to say how many they have and complain about what terrible conditions they are living in. If those were my children I would ask for them to be taken from me if I had to stay in a camp like that. But the kids are just pawns in the system because they are the card to play on the hearts of their home countries. I don’t understand why there is no sign of Red Cross or UN Aid? The whole thing is bat sh!t crazy
I feel sorry for the children and the lady who went to Syria at the age of 15 she was very young and deserves a second chance. The kids need to be taken away from these people before they turn them into terrorists. This thing of being too open to date anyone could be dangerous sometimes, because you may not know that you are dating a member of ISIS until you are married.
The women – well you made that choice now live with it … absolutely no sympathy for the women who chose to marry these men .. I mean what did you think life was going be like there .. filled with roses and rainbows?? … the children on the other hand that’s a different story ..I hope those kids are rescued and given a good life…
watch an interview with a Yazidi Girl and you can see real suffering. Also Al Hol camp is actually better equipped than the camps housing actual refuges. I hate the fact that I feel very little sympathy for these women. I can see that there is trauma there, and most of them are young and they clearly have PTSD but there is a lot of self denial and self pity, without taking any responsibility. that being said the children shouldn’t be there.
I know that some people when nervous, laugh and cannot control it, however, it seemed very strange and insincere to me the way that she was laughing while she was relating her story… It might not be, but that is how I felt… Ridiculous that in the 21st century, in civilized places, people are still manipulated, ‘tricked’ or even attracted by adventure, whatever the reason…and then they cry for help….Because of the ignorance and stupidity of some who are brainwashed, others who really need help and were indeed mistreated, are not believed and forgotten…Who do you trust? Those beautiful children though have no choice, I feel for them….
These men r extremely able in getting a woman to fall in love with them and tying them down by having some children… I’m 65yrs old, alone, English, living in Italy & it’s very common for a poor black immigrant to be extremely charming when “courting” me; the same on Social Media – I’ve had (pretty sure) terrorists wanting to make friends… there’s been so many cases of lonely middle-aged ladies being duped out of their savings by these Arabian Princes
Can anyone tell me when this four corners episode first went to air it’s the 30th of september 2021 right now. Are they still fighting in syria? man this islamic stae has tones of money it seems to me. All the way from Kondel Park one or two surburbs away from semi_industrial /residential Bankstown where i was born in april 1977. Such a long way from home.
They want to game the system, little by little…The guy says, “bring them back here and detain, atleast we know they are safe. We will deal with the legalities later..” He is saying he has the human rights game to play later, but he has to use the same system to bring the beautiful brides back…LET THEM ROT IN THE HOLE…
It is difficult to feel compassion for these people who deny any responsibility for entering a war zone, where they had to make considerable effort to get there, being a participant, willing or not, in an organization that performed all forms of horrendous depravity against their fellow human beings, under a convenient interpretation of the Koran and now living in squaller in another unfriendly foreign land demand mercy and to return to their former lives in Australia as if nothing ever happened! I think not. They should have to be held responsible for their deeds in some way.
The fact that they are asking ‘what have they done’… 🤦🏾♀️ seriously?? So their families are out here asking for them to be removed from the hellish camps they are in.. what should the families of all those killed by that demonic group ask for? I feel for the children. I truly do. But it comes down to choosing us over them. Our safety matters. What we want, matters. I would not risk bringing them back in. Every country has a right to protect its citizens and should not be badgered into taking them back in. I count the cost and it’s too high. They may consider seeking refuge from any other country willing to take the risk.
I don’t feel sorry for these women. They knew exactly what they were doing. These women are Australian, so they can’t claim they are poor people who don’t know better. They absolutely knew what they were doing and now want to claim innocence. I wouldn’t bring them back until the war ends. The children I do feel sorry for though.
My heart breaks for their children. All those children are caught between one’s parent insanity – the fathers and whatever crossed their mother’s minds when they had them. The mothers do not deserve a second chance, in my opinion, but the children are a different matter. How do you solve this? Whatever solution, it means separating from their parents. So..lose lose. What situation they put themselves in…
Those poor innocent babies, stuck in a cycle of hate that they can’t leave. They deserve a better life – why can’t people take those babies and bring them home. If any of those woman were truly stuck there for innocent reasons and wanted out, they would happily send they’re babies home to they’re families to have a better life. I would. In a heartbreak. Breaks my heart for those children 💔
Well as a Muslim girl I feel this is right for the women who joined ISIS to be not allowed to come back. I feel terrible for those children they didn’t do anything they’re so innocent. On the other hand playing devil’s advocate I also think many of these girls in some capacity were groomed and manipulated to join ISIS too. Haven’t we considered that? There are many doc series how people were groomed and manipulated to do stuff don’t these women count in that category? Many of them were under age when they joined. But that just a thought, maybe I’m wrong! But i hope they find a way to take those innocent children from there and give them a better life! They deserve better. They didn’t do anything. It would be also nice if these women realized they have made a mistake and not just be so “privileged” and think there government would take them back just because they are citizens of a country, well you should have thought about it BEFORE leaving to join a terrorist group. Don’t use words like it’s not fair. Show some regret that you realise you have made a big big big mistake. It’s not the country responsibility to bring you back just because you are a citizen
My heart is torn for the children stuck in this mess, it really is, they did not ask to be born. What their parents have done is atrocious and they don’t even seem sorry, just full of self pity. So it a tough situation. What on earth compelled these people to join a terrorist organisation like how did that seem like an attractive idea??? I was a teenager not long ago and even at that age it’s not hard to tell right from wrong!
Husband got her to a war torn country and they had 4 children!!! Meanwhile the thought of having a second child and the responsibilities associated send shivers down my spine even though me and my wife earn well in a peaceful country… So NO, I don’t feel sorry for you!!! Children of Somalian refugees in Europe went back to fight in Syria. Its going to be the same thing if these women come back… They made their choice…
At 46:30 it’s epic when she says, “they don’t understand the concept of a line”, it shows she doesn’t understand eastern culture. I feel the same way when I go to India, there, they don’t understand a que system. If you want to get on a bus for example, you have to push people mercilessly, to get on it, or wait around for hours til an empty one comes, no one stands in a line to get on the bus everyone just pushes each other. Whether they’re female, pregnant whatever, it doesn’t matter, it’s all about survival over there.
Tough situation. Some may have been tricked, made a poor choice, a mistake. Some may have willingly gone. Just want to say what about the women who may have been trapped and realised they made a mistake or unfairly been put in a life they cant come back from. Of course they are all a very high risk but I feel it is more fair to consider different scenarios than one where they are all believed to be terrorists.
My Muslim friends watch their children like hawks, and won’t let them just attend any mosque activity, etc. They teach them religious Islam within a modern world. I’m sorry but some of these parents need to take responsibility. This is what they taught their children, and their children just found those who implemented what they have been taught. This is very sad all around
There keeps being a very large gap in how this happened. They all say I was with my parents, I went to a “cafe, I E. and all of a sudden I’m married to a stranger. No my family reported me missing, you have to work hard to get to a war torn country let alone boarders in the desert. There parents either both or one have led them to this or left out large portions. I come from a very classist background and I can understand a little about higharhy but there just mass gaps. At least take the children back, the babies are obviously innocent and these girls their family religion has some blame!
I wrote a comment on someone else’s comment earlier saying these women have no remorse…… I have now rewatched this and I am changing my views. I now think there is a chance these women didn’t know what was going on, I think they were use to following their husbands. I think their strange behaviours are a mixture of so many emotions, the smiling is nerves, the crying is the fact they are at a loss of what to do next. And I think a lot of it is they are just numb after so many years of living to survive. If there is no evidence they took part in any fighting etc. Then I think Australia need to assess each woman on a one to one basis. Perhaps they need to set up a form of camp/detainment in Australia for them to be kept for a number of years while they are rehabilitated, assessed given psychological help, where the kids are educated and given medical support. I mentioned in the other comment about a British woman (I am British) who went out to ISIS with 2 others when they were 15. They went out knowing they were to sneak into Syria, to marry ISIS men, and even learn to fight. This woman, her husband now dead, and all her children have died too, now wants to return home, but in her interviews she still stands by what she did, she has no remorse for those who died by the hand of her husband and still believes in a lot of their values. She truly is a danger. She has even gone as far as wearing western clothing to prove she has changed, but you can tell her mind is still there same.
If they get those people back to Australia 🇦🇺the taxpayers will have to look after them, besides the fact that they are stuck there is part of thier bad choices, as regards the women who apparently didn’t know what was happening, that is hearsay, this is war so sorry people will fall through the cracks.
The only ones I feel sorry for are the innocent babies and children. Information about ISIS are widely available to anyone…how could they claimed not to have known anything? What about those selling their properties and funding ISIS? What’s their excuse? Australia does not want to bring back people that could pose a threat to our national security.
No way. We do not want these woman back. They made their choice but the kids didn’t so I think the kids should be able to come here but the sick thing is that if the children were allowed to come to Australia, these selfish woman wouldn’t let them go as they would then know, they have no bargaining tools left. They are just using these poor kids. You don’t love your kid if you give birth to it in a warzone.
They both seem quite excited what they went through, in the war. They chose to go there and were looking for fighters to marry and support. They thought that was the way it would always be and had it been different they would not be begging to be allowed home. They would probably be involved in terrorist attacks and the planning and the killing of innocents in their home countries and others. Let the children return to safe family members, the are the innocents. Let those now in power in Syria decide the rate of the girls and women who may have blood on their hands. They knew where going to Syria and they knew why. I know some who went to join ISIS have been accepted back by some countries. ISIS is on the rise again and letting any back in was so wrong and we have daily arrivals of just who? In the UK? Madness!
Children should not be held in ANY detention camp. They are not responsible for their parents crimes and to hold these children is criminal. If you believe in the hereafter and judgement for your sins, then this is a big one. Also these same children may become a threat the longer you hold them. Suffering breeds deep hatred and that indifference towards those kids may end up biting the powers that be right in the ass. Educate them instead in the wisdom of tolerance and forgiveness and the sanctity of life and fear of these children will prove to be unjustified.
They don’t even have the wherewithal to keep up the self pity during the entire duration of the interview. Smiling and joking. Every time I opened my mouth I would speak as if the people who decided if I could come home, were listening to me. Now is not the time to win mrs congeniality.ALSO: YOURE RIGHT!!!! WE DONT KNOW WHAT THE SOUND OF THOSE BOMBS AND GUNS WERE LIKE, BECAUSE WE DIDN’T LEAVE OUR COUNTRY TO FIGHT FOR ISIS